Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Speaker wire? Are you sure? Network cable has it all wrong for speaker cable.

Speakers are typically around 4-8 ohm. With long cables, it is easy to get several ohms of resistance, meaning a significant part of the current is going to end up heating the cable instead of producing sound. Not only it is a waste, but impedance is frequency-dependent, so sound quality will be affected. It is not audiophile bullshit, you can hear it clearly. What you need are the thickest and shortest cables that you can reasonable use. For very long distances, active speakers are preferable, or a high voltage (typically 100V) line and transformers.

Interference doesn't matter. You are putting lots of power in these wires, enough to move the speaker membranes, then move the air, then move your eardrums. Compared to that, what you get from external sources is negligible. If you hear humming, that's a ground loop, and your speaker wires are not at fault.

Now CAT5 cable could make great subwoofer cables. I don't know, but it kind of makes sense. Subwoofer cables are low current, and therefore more likely to pickup parasites. They also tend to be longer than typical interconnects. So shielding and twisting may help.



The resistance of copper cable is often overstated. Quality network cable has about 0.1 ohm/m/direction. So two pairs in paralel for each direction (4 wires), for a total of 5m should have about 0.25 ohm total resistance. I wouldn't say audiophile approved, but probably very close to undetectable for most, both regarding the loss and the response.


> but probably very close to undetectable for most, both regarding the loss and the response.

Yah. Take an 8 ohm speaker, which might vary from 5 to 20 ohms, but is relatively close to 8 ohms for much of its range.

At 5 ohms, your voltage is attenuated by 5% -- this is -0.45dB. Re: the "heating the cable" waste, you're losing .45 dB of sound output to heat.

At 20 ohms, your voltage is attenuated by almost nothing (.05 dB).

In any room, and with any real driver and amplifier you're going to have far bigger concerns for flatness of response than this .4 dB variation.

Bigger concerns are--- having something stranded and chonkier with big thick insulation is good for robustness and strain relief instead of trying to abuse network cables (even stranded) for the job. You can get thicker, nicer wire for this purpose than network cable for less money.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: