Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Western Digital boss most disliked tech CEO in survey (blocksandfiles.com)
37 points by caution on Oct 9, 2023 | hide | past | favorite | 8 comments


I’m surprised Nadella is at 30% approval. Honestly doesn’t feel that way from the inside. These surveys from blind probably have a severe bias because the site attracts people that are disgruntled to begin with.


Didn't he announce that people's raises were capped at like 3% despite crazy inflation at the time or something like that? I can't imagine I'd be a happy employee if my pay got stunted while way up the food chain these people are making millions.


FWIW, Glassdoor shows >90% approval for Nadella: https://www.glassdoor.com/Overview/Working-at-Microsoft-EI_I...


> These surveys from blind probably have a severe bias because the site attracts people that are disgruntled to begin with.

That doesn't explain the high approval ratings of other companies. Clearly some companies are treating their employees shittier than others.


It doesn’t explain why other anonymous ratings like from the one on Glassdoor are 90%+. There must be some selection bias.


Well, with Glassdoor it is much simpler: they are very trigger-happy to erase unfavorable ratings and comments upon a request from the company. It isn’t some conspiracy theory or a secret, it’s been known for a while, with plenty reporting and articles about it.

I also don’t know absolutely anyone in big tech/FAANG who takes glassdoor seriously or even uses it at all.

Not that Blind is the pure truth or anything when it comes to absolute approval numbers, it is just the other side of the same coin (with the jaded ones gravitating more towards it).

However, when it comes to relative approval ratings among companies (i.e., to determine which one has higher approval vs another, not how good in absolute terms it is), I would definitely go with Blind.


Well you’re implying bias on Glassdoor’s part, I don’t see why the same couldn’t be true of Blind, albeit in a different way.


There is bias on both sides, and I never said otherwise. However, the one difference is that Blind team doesn’t remove comments and reviews critical of companies at request of those companies, while it has been public knowledge for a long time that Glassdoor does.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: