Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The video won’t play for me, but does this allow tweaking of parameters? The problem with most projects like this one is that it replicates the sound of a certain pedal with certain settings. That’s a major problem for most guitarists as playing with the knobs live is a big part of the attraction to pedals.



No, it doesn't. But to be honest, this would be next level. When looking at this, I'm thinking of alternatives and I can only name 2:

1 - Kemper Profiler

2 - NeuralDSP

Both of them are above 1000€/$. We are talking about 10x the price of this thing. Add some Multi-FX Pedal (like Line6 HX-Stomp) where you put this in the FX-Loop and you end up with something equally good for still half the price.

And in general, its not about what is better, digital or analog. It's about the use-case. In the studio or when noodling around with the knobs when practicing: Real Amps and Pedals. But on stage, you don't play with the settings of your pedals or you want presets. This is where you go digital. No one will notice the slightly different sound there anyway.


I played out live for a decade and absolutely used the knobs on my pedals live. Most musicians I knew with a pedalboard did the same.

That said, if you use a preset based effects setup like rackmount gear, I could see how this would be cool.


Yeah, true. But you would only change it between songs, I guess, and only to the values you always use for that song, right? - This is what I would capture and use as a preset, preset change triggered by MIDI from the MultiFX unit.

I know some who change their settings during playing, but I wouldn't consider this as standard. Also, you can still add a real Pedal to a MultiFX Board if you really want to change its settings live. On the contrary, automatically changing the settings controlled by your DAW and triggered via MIDI into your MultiFX unit is also pretty common. You don't have to hassle with your Effects at all and can concentrate on playing, what you should, as you need to be absolutely on point.


I designed and built a eurorack module around a pi zero with a usb audio input/output, voltage divider, op amp, and some pots connected to adc. Using rtaudio the latency was pretty low and gave me control of the parameters I wanted.

Given that this was the only really active process on the pi, it ended up working really well. I simply converted modules I had written for vcv rack.

I also built one that enabled usb host mode and acted as an audio device that worked with any daw. Ended up being pretty cool for about $20 of parts.

While not as cool as an ml system, given that I was already writing dsp, it ended up being pretty neat.


not quite there yet, but on possibility is train multiple models and switch between them on the fly

another is add more params to the models to take the knob states into the account when doing predictions (which can impact the performance)




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: