Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

But your genetic disorder shouldn’t be extended to negatively impact others, knowing your unique situation means you need to manage your risks. It’s entirely unfair and a violation of privacy for people to have to be brought into your health decisions and vice versa. Why would it ever be reasonable to expect the government to keep tabs on random strangers just because I have a genetic health condition?

I would much rather die than force someone else to suddenly be required to base their free agency around what happens to work best for me, especially because I am 100% going to die no matter what.

It just seems totally illogical to remove freedoms at scale to prevent something that is ultimately inevitable.

Basically seems like throwing the baby out with the bath water, what’s the point of having a society at all if people have to be micro-managed to the point of being enslaved to each other’s mortality? It just seems so obviously a mistake and a huge slippery slope.

What’s next, they tell us which people have to die so the rest of us don’t have to be burdened with them? That is essentially exactly what this type of government/healthcare overreach is doing.



I shouldn't have to tell people I have a genetic disorder to have them respect my desire to keep their damn hands off of me.

Expecting random strangers to not touch me is not some huge invasive expectation. Quite the contrary: The people who think they are entitled to touch me are being invasive and making an imposition. People should not feel that because I'm poor or an attractive woman or whatever that touching me is appropriate behavior when we are total strangers.

That's just one example and I don't intend to discuss this further with you.


I very much agree to getting rid of the mandatory handshaking habit. And quite some similar customs. Like in the supermarket yesterday, with everyone wearing masks, limited people inside etc. - but then at the cashier I was expected to use the same dirty digital pen to sign the payment by card, like everybody else did. Such idiocity.

But for the rest, do you expect people to continiue to wear masks after this?

In general, are you aware, that the youth of this planet is pretty much on standby since a year? They are not really threatened by covid, yet they have to pay the highest toll in the restrictions - because their life is not established, they have to move around to set up their life. Which they cannot really do now. They could also say, fuck the old and weak, we won't sacrifice more for them - we got to live our lives now - but they are largely not doing it. So maybe it is not such a shitty egoistic world after all?


But for the rest, do you expect people to continiue to wear masks after this?

No, I don't expect people to wear masks as the new norm.

I haven't managed to write in earnest because I think people treat masks like plus two magic items in the game of Pandemic and I mostly hate them and this is not exactly a good place from which to gain an audience and yadda under current circumstances.


Oh, that is surprising, I mean, I hate the masks, too, but my immune system is quite good, so I wear it only for the sake of other people. May I ask, why you object to masks for yourself?


I guess I was deleting that line as you were writing.

Sorry, I don't really want to get into it. That seems like a shit show waiting to happen and all downside.


Thats allright. I suspect it has to do with the breathing impact and potentially accumulating of germs inside the mask?


You do realize health is not a "me" problem?

It is an "US" problem. Frankly, we have a number of US problems brewing and we have them due to not having our priorities in order as a people, human beings.


Another way of looking at it is that most people are incompetent at being selfish.

A competently selfish person would realize that having compassion for their fellow human beings is one of the most selfish traits they could ever have.


Indeed. The advantages add right up quickly. In my view, that it does not all end up in a spreadsheet or bank account makes this a harder discussion than it needs to be.


Genuinely curious where you got that idea, my health is absolutely none of your business.


Yes it is. We live in a closed ecosystem.

Mother Nature has boundary issues.

I understand you hold that opinion. Also understand it is a minority opinion. And hey, I get it. Many people do not like to be told what they have to do.

Humans, this place we inhabit works the way it works. There will be tradeoffs.

Managing public health is one of them. There are many others.

Sincerely, I wish you had the option to live in a personal vacuum, "you do you" style, but that option is currently unavailable.

There are some options given you are willing to either forego many of the benefits that come with a well developed society, or accumulate wealth sufficient to isolate yourself.

Barring those, yeah. You are just another member of the public.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: