Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> We've been reckless

I worked around nuclear weapon systems and TBH came away with the opposite impression. I grew up terrified of the military and panic mongering about of "THE BOMBS!" from family, media, etc. But after this, I ironically came away feeling much safer seeing how professional and serious people took their jobs.




> I grew up terrified of the military and panic mongering about of "THE BOMBS!"

It's probably not intended that way, but the above is a bit of a strawman. There are many serious reasons to be concerned.

For example, a few years ago it was discovered that the Air Force units operating the missiles had very low morale, there was widespread cheating on qualification exams, significant disregard for safety regulations, and a problem with drug use. Also, the general in charge had a drinking problem so bad that he went on a binge in Moscow.

Before that, it was discovered that the Air Force lost track of several nuclear weapons. The Secretary of Defense at the time, Bob Gates, fired multiple Air Force leaders.

Outside the missile field, maybe 10 years ago peaceful civilian protestors penetrated a complex storing highly enriched uranium or plutonium (weapons-grade materials, IIRC), and spent something like 20 minutes adjacent to the building containing the materials before security discovered them.

IMHO, with something this dangerous, the greatest threat is complacence and trust. We are dealing with human beings who we are requiring to be vigilant over a period of generations - something people are very poor at for even a short time. Trust, but verify said Reagan of the Soviet Union, and that applies to our side too.


Some nuclear plant worker told the same on reddit. We're all very concerned about nuclear plant since Fukushima and we all saw mistakes. But the guy basically said he wouldn't work in any other place considering how well it was done and operated.


Fukushima should be an eye opener because that mistake and accident cost many lives. It made innocents suffer due to health problems.. who might never recover.


> accident cost many lives

There were none:

"there were no deaths caused by acute radiation syndrome. Given the uncertain health effects of low-dose radiation, cancer deaths cannot be ruled out. However, no discernible increase in the rate of cancer deaths is expected."[0]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_Daiichi_nuclear_disa...


News reported the state of the area a year after but I didn't check since, it would be interesting to see how they coped with the event.


I'd be curious what your takeaway is from the book.

At one point one of the regulators in the Safety Commission stopped receiving reports about accidents because the Air Force knew that this would be used as ammunition to fix the Titan II safety issues that had been in place for decades.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: