Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | henryw's comments login

I'm wondering this too since Windows has built-in antivirus now. https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/comprehensive-securi...


Windows has had "Microsoft Security Essentials" built-in for longer than I can remember (10+ years?). It's not a terrible thing and keeps out of your way and doesn't seem to bog your machine down. Unlike the steaming pile of crap that my work computer runs (EndPoint) that consumes 60-80% CPU when doing its weekly full scan for over an hour right in the middle of the working day.

MSE is really all I've used since binning AVG which turned into bloatware.


Took me a while to figure out why my browsers always seem to randomly pause for about 30 seconds. It's that piece of crap McCaffee. I can watch it's process go to 100% when the browser (firefox and vivaldi) freeze. It's garbage and I wish I could turn it off and just use MS AV but the IT staff swear by McAffee so I live with it.


> but the IT staff swear by McAffee

I feel your pain. We have a load of other crap loaded such as Umbrella that is supposed to protect us from harmful websites. It does stuff like intercept DNS lookups etc. It's such a pile of shite and doesn't work properly when I need VPN into our cloud infrastructure. When it's configured so badly it feels really anti-work. But hey ho, "security reasons".


Dr. Sinclair's book Lifespan (https://www.amazon.com/Lifespan-Why-Age_and-Dont-Have/dp/150...) talks about extending the health span of people. I've been personally taking 1g/day of NMN for almost 3 years now, and I feel like aging has paused or is going backwards slowly.


I am willing to wager that Dr Sinclair is just peddling nonsense to make his million bucks and exit quickly.


considering he leads a research group at Harvard that publishes in high profile journals, you could actually look at the peer reviewed research, instead of relying on your "hunch"


It's old news but did you know, He did fuck GSK for 750 million? Basically no one could ever replicate his study. GSK should have done thier homework so boohoo for them but still all is not what it seems.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JAFnD27ffqE


Well at least he isn't exiting quickly after having made his million bucks. I sometimes take NMN. I have no idea if it works or not.


How old are you?

How are you gauging “aging has paused or is going backwards slowly”?


Mid 30s. Gauging by how my joints feel and how quickly I recover from physical exercise and injuries.


I’m 38. I’ve beaten the hell out of my poor aging frame. And then fixed a lot of those injuries to my poor aging frame by not playing rugby any more.

All of which to say: there is absolutely no way you are possibly controlling for all variables here. Things off the top of my head that could help with exercise recovery, all of which are more plausible than some poorly tested supplement:

- Changes in exercise type - Changes in exercise duration - Changes in exercise intensity - Changes in exercise form - Weight loss - Sleeping more for better recovery


He's also launched a podcast-- https://www.youtube.com/c/DavidSinclairPodcast/videos

I find the first 3 episodes to be absolutely stellar and was engrossed the whole hour. Pretty good takeaways.

The more recent ones are a little contentious and, as he himself admits, a little pseudosciency. He even says that these supplements are marginally helpful, and perhaps the most beneficial things is literally to just walk after a meal. Partially as a result, and partially because the recent episodes's concepts weren't explained well, I found myself distracted.

Random-- he makes a comment how the FDA often prematurely bans things e.g. peptides, which greatly hampers researchers' access to these materials.


I'm going to save you some money. What really works well and better than taking NMN orally(), eat a natural clean whole food diet (no pufa's or processed food), no alcohol or smoking and walk or do some sort of light exercise for about 30-60 minutes a day.

I am willing to bet it will do more for you than taking NMN.

Peter Attia has discussed this with folks who know a lot more than Sinclair and they have concluded there is no evidence it works. The number one thing you can do to extend lifespan is exercise.


but what if I do all of the above?


You would get healthy and waste money on NMN.


Where can you get NMN?


Don't bother. Sinclair is considered a quack by even some life-extension enthusiasts.

He owns part of the company that makes patented NMN which is just another form of NR which is a another form of very cheap Niacin.

He also owns part of the company that claims he is rolling back his biological clock.

That's not science, that's marketing and profiteering.

NAD production slows down with age and illness. All he is doing is supplementing what was produced more easily by a younger body.

There are a many other factors to aging, most of which cannot be changed (yet) by science.


I am doing some experiments with NR (no Sinclair in the business chain AFAIK) and pterostilbene and my ability to exercise has improved noticeably. I am 43 and I used to be fairly sore after a strenuous 60 minute exercise - especially my sinews were bad. This wasn't getting any better with more exercise, actually it was slowly getting worse with age, to the degree that I wasn't able to exercise in two consecutive days and sometimes I had to wait until the third day to go to the gym again. (To be clear, I am neither fat nor riddled with any serious disease.)

Nowadays the small pains and aches go away in a few hours, like when I was some 15 years younger. But if I stop the supplementation, the situation reverts to the old bad standard within a month or so.

I also noticed some effect on my visual acuity.

I know this is N == 1, hard to measure precisely and subject to a possible placebo effect.


I had a similar response doing a mostly vegan calorie restricted low protein diet. I was blown away because I had always been told protein = recovery, calories = recovery, but I have been able to rock climb pretty hard 6 days a week for the past 4 months now. Keto, general healthy eating, tons of supplements and all the other things I have tried have resulted in maybe 3-4 hard sessions a week and achy joints.


Note I am not disputing NAD supplementation, only the limits of what it can do and who can benefit from it.

The key to NAD supplementation is the people who need it are older or ill.

There are a lot of other processes in such bodies that become deficient too.

None of the supplement methods for NAD, Niacin, NR, NMN will boost levels beyond what your body will use.

This is what the NAD cycle looks like, you can see NA (niacin) vs NR vs NMN are each closer to production but the end result is the same of what ends up in the blood vs organs like liver.

https://www.lifespan.io/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/NAD_schem...

There are wild arguments, even with scientific rigor, about NR vs NMN ability to get into cells. It is more likely that genetics matters and it varies from person to person and what else is in their diet.


Why disregard someone simply because they own a piece of a company that also supports the goal? I think any rational person would do the same - you believe in something so you start, invest in, or advise a company.


I think the comment also said that this person’s views aren’t taken seriously in the aging research community. So the combination of their ideas and a desire to profit from them raises flags.


I don't think Harvard would let Sinclair have a lab with some 35 people and publish articles under their name if he was a total fraud/quack.

My impression of Sinclair is that he likes public attention too much and often reports on work in progress with too much certainty, but results like this [1] seem to be fairly impressive.

[1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2975-4


Counterpoint from someone more educated (with a more precise conclusion that he is "not evidence based")

https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1492902239312039938.html



There is no evidence it works taken orally. Save your money.


Can this be made into bulletproof clothing that looks like normal clothes? That would be cool


UHMWPE already can do that.


This reminds me of the movie The Island where they cloned people as organ backups https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0399201/.


If you want to explore the concept further, I suggest you watch the movie "Never Let Me Go" (2010). The premise is very similar, apart from the fact there's no secret or conspiracy about it, children are just grown to become sacrificial organ donors, and since it's socially accepted, there's no way out of it.

Fair warning: it's pretty depressing.


I second this recommendation. And "The Island" is 100% the Hollywood / Michael Bay version of that story.


Based on a book by the same name. I haven't watched the film but I can recommend the book.


Atea Pharmaceutical is finishing up phase 3 trial of a Covid anti-viral pill in November that might be more effective (based on phase 2 trial data) and doesn't mutate the virus: https://ateapharma.com/at-527/


I think long covid is temporary for most people. I had it for 4 months last year and have recovered. Got to stay positive through out it, have faith it’ll get better, and do everything you can to stay healthy


What are some examples of $HYPED_TECHNOLOGY and $FLASHY_LANGUAGE these days? All I can remember is Ruby on Rails.


Just sprinkle some magic Kubernetes on your problems and they'll all go away! Oh, and make sure you add a Service Mesh too... just in case.


Kubernetes makes way more problems than what it solves in my company. We even migrated to another cloud provider, hoping for a better managed kubernetes. We ended up with different bugs and issues and a worse than useless support in a different timezone, in addition to a much more expensive cloud bill.


There's no good managed k8s anywhere. You can get bad managed k8s cheaply from Digital Ocean, or expensively from EKS or GKS, whose pricing and service levels are broadly similar. The major difference is that, if you do >$100M ARR and have EKS spend to match, you can expect to have several TAMs available, at least one of whom will usually understand what they're all taking turns apologizing for this time. Google, by contrast, will never give a shit about you no matter who you are, and charges slightly more for this service.


React, Typescript, GraphQL, Rust and Go more recently. But there’s been plenty since and prior to Rails. I remember all the Java hotness.


"Serverless"

(which looks an awful lot like cgi-bin and shared hosting all over again)


Blockchain and Rust. You get five ironic moustaches if it compiles to web assembly.


At least web assembly brings us something completely new that we never had before. Rust is just an attempt to improve things, which is fine! But, it needs a decades long proven track record to come close to competing with Java/C++/PHP, which takes time obviously.


I think the cool kids are moving to DOS on Dope or Cobol on Cogs.


As someone leading the charge moving a company from Rails on Heroku to Go on Kubernetes with Prometheus/Jaeger/Fluentd/$CNCF I’ll be self aware enough to say “all of the latter.”


Elixir, Node, Scala, Go, React, SPAs in general


* Anything CSS-in-JS

* any new Nxxt.js framework that looks a lot like PHP 4, with HTML, SQL and JavaScript mixed all over the place.


Node.js itself was the new hotness for a while.


Java on Javascript is the cool thing these days


Are you referring to typescript? If so, that’s hilarious


Mostly Rust and yet another JS framework.


It's at $0.28 right now https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/CLK20.NYM?p=CLK20.NYM

Update: -$35.53 now


it hit 0 for a bit


"The KCDC said it took 13.5 days on average for people to be retested positive for COVID-19 after being released from quarantine."

Maybe they were never fully recovered.


I’m thinking some people pulled strings to get discharged early. South Korea is sequestering people in hospitals if they’re positive, and that’s not exactly a fun experience.


What is the local bank?


First Bank of Colorado (https://www.efirstbank.com/) - I've moved away from CO over a decade ago but kept all my personal banking there. (No affiliation.)


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: