Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | _m_p's commentslogin

Sounds profoundly anti-humanist.


What you mean by "humanist" does not seem to be what philosophers mean by it.


Sounds like "memetics" gives agency to writing as a thing independent of human beings doing writing, which is an interesting frame but also untrue.



Yeah, well, that's just how the humanism meme wants to instrumentalize you at this moment.


This is a good way for these books to signal what they are like to their readership (bad).


> Also, because of the expensive infrastructure that can only be used by trams, there’s a permanence there that prevents future politicians from ripping it out to put more cars on for a quick political win with drivers.

This is definitively not true. It's something people said about the Washington, DC streetcar and it turns out they are about to remove the streetcar in order to replace it with buses:

https://www.railwaygazette.com/light-rail-and-tram/dc-street...


I would have hoped it was clear that I never stated infrastructure was never ripped out, since there have been numerous examples of this happening, including my own home city. I’m merely making the point that tearing up tram lines is more costly than simply paying someone to cut paint lines off the road. That plus the initial investment creates an inertia against undoing it, though nothing prevents politicians pissing public money up the wall if they’re determined enough.



In this vein, people might be interested in reading about the Dawson City Film Find!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dawson_Film_Find

> In 1929, Clifford Thomson, then employed by the Canadian Bank of Commerce and also treasurer of the hockey association, solved the problem of the library's stock of film and the inadequate ice rink. Thomson took 500,000 feet of film and stacked the reels in the pool, covered the reels with boards and leveled the rink with a layer of earth. The DAAA continued to receive new nitrate films which would later fuel the destruction of the entire complex in a fire in 1951. The films stored under the ice rink were preserved by permafrost and were later uncovered in 1978 when a new recreation center was being built.


English lit as a discipline has pretty strongly repudiated the discipline of "close reading" (and the "New Criticism" that buttressed it; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Criticism) in favor of whatever else it is that English professors now do in classes, so it's not surprising that...

> The competent readers in our study... constituted 38 percent (or 32 of the 85) of our subjects

Seems like there's a strong case for moving English 101 type classes, which are required and very heavily subsidize the existence of English departments, into Communications or elsewhere.


There is a strong case for reading the whole report and realizing it is hot garbage, it takes aim at high school reading competency. Take your Doge Whistles somewhere else. /end


Literate enough to insinuate that the report is worth critiquing; not literate enough to do the critique.


This book is particularly great about discussing the process of filmmaking, which in Malick's case often seems to involve a ton of experimentation through editing in order to shape a film after photography had finished.

(Some of this editing work notably led to major actors having their roles cut from films. Adrien Brody, for example, apparently believed that he was going to have the lead role in _The Thin Red Line_ but ended up entirely cut.)

For those interested, Richard Brody's book about Godard and Carrie Rickey's book about Agnes Varda are similarly detailed about the specifics of their filmmaking work!


Those interested may also really like this article about the cinematography of _Days of Heaven_: https://theasc.com/articles/photographing-days-of-heaven

> My work became "de-illuminating," that is, removing the false and conventional light.


Every film cited in this article is meant to cater to the existing tastes of the audience and people like having their existing tastes reaffirmed.

One can watch other films. For example: https://www.bfi.org.uk/lists/chantal-akerman-10-essential-fi...


Yep, Jeanne Dielman, 23 quai du Commerce, 1080 Bruxelles (1975) is one of the "1001 Movies".

I confess, I was not patient with the film. I scrubbed a bit to move the film along at a faster pace — almost skipped right over the wild ride that is the end of the film.


Which elements of this book haven't been totally debunked?


Yah I heard about people trying to debunk it over the years, with zero effect.


If economists are so smart, why aren't they rich?


diminishing to negative marginal returns to wealth past ~80k salary

(famous economic study)


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: