Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> And she managed many of her breakthroughs after the passing of her husband Pierre in 1906, who slipped and fell in the rain on a busy Paris street and was run over by the wheels of a horse-drawn cart.

Even back then, people were dying much more of traffic incidents than radioactivity exposure. Yet people fear radioactivity way more than taking their own car.



You are twisting reality to fit your views :-)

You need to compare the % of people driving cars vs dying on car accidents, vs the people working with highly radio-active material (without protection at the time) vs people dying from radio-active material under that specific conditions :-)


Well, a different premise, but still exemplifying people's fear of radio-active material: nuclear power is still way less deadly than oil (actually, by a factor of 400 or so) [1].

[1] http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-de...


I've heard this claim very often, but I can never be sure if the fatalities includes those from Uranium mining which was historically very dangerous and did cause many deaths in the former Eastern Bloc.

A lot of the fatalities are from coal, not oil or natural gas. Coal is much more widely used than nuclear energy, so I'm not sure if they were used on the same amount which would have more casualties.

Not to mention that this depends on the country as well, since countries differ wildly in terms of workplace safety and the existence/enforcement of environmental standarts.

I would avoid repeating this claim.


Coal is at around ~10x the generation of nuclear.

The nuclear death rate is ~1/375 that of coal. This is because emissions are a major contributor to the death rate for coal.

Looking it up, the first analysis I find says that uranium ore is likely more energy dense than coal[1] so it shouldn't be the case that it is a lot more dangerous than coal mining.

[1] http://www.plux.co.uk/energy-density-of-uranium/




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: