Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

As one of a small niche group who hosts Hubot on Heroku, this is horrible news. Chatroom bots are useless if they aren't in a room 24/7; that's the only reason why we have a keepalive. It's not as if the chat bot is doing a lot of computation, but this really does make it sound like I'll have to toss Heroku despite the convenience factor with it.



Or pay $7 per month?


It's for an open source project, not an internal work instance or anything. As a student at uni with no full time job, adding more monthly charges is hard to deal with.


At Georgia Tech we got a very small server space which was used in a few CS classes, it would have been large enough to run hubot. Your university might have a similar setup.


Heroku was basically becoming the go-to place to run thousands of little bots—and more importantly, to advise people to run their little bots—without thinking about marginal costs. It was becoming everyone's little pocket of persistent personal cloud agents. The "launch on Heroku" button on Github pages was a thing you could just press on a whim as a realistic solution to your problem.

Now none of that's true.


IBM's Bluemix has a very generous free tier. If you can run an app or apps using a total of 512M of ram with modest data storage requirements, then that is free.


Move it to digital ocean?

https://education.github.com/pack


I'd try to scrounge some old computer from your CS department or buy a raspberry pi and run it on that.


Old computer, yeah- Raspberry Pi, not so much. Takes hours to compile node from source, and I've only been able to find one source for ARM node binaries.

And after all that, hubot still ran pretty damn slow. :(


Presumably you'd buy a Rasberry Pi v2 that has arm v7, and can run full/regular Debian with a proper kernel?

https://wiki.debian.org/RaspberryPi

Still, Debian only ships nodejs 0.10 (even Sid) for now -- and I'm not sure what the status is for compiling node 0.12 on armv7 (it apparently has issues on armv6 which the rpi v1 runs).

Fwiw, if you can get by with node 0.10 for hubot (Which I think you can[1]?) -- there shouldn't be any problem:

http://archive.raspbian.org/raspbian/pool/main/n/nodejs/

Unless you need to compile your own nodejs binary for some reason?

[1] https://github.com/github/hubot/blob/master/package.json


I have a bunch of little open source, public service sorts of things too

Don't know what I'm going to do with them. They're useless if they're not up 24/7, but I can't justify wasting $84 a year on them either.


It should be possible to install hubot on a small OpenShift gear.


So because you are a student you think people have to provide you with free computers?


Pretty sure you can get a cheap VPS for less than that and it will allow you to do much more.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: