Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> They can't legally ask for proof, no. Bluff away!

Well, I am a lawyer, and this is also not legal advice.

To lie and accept a job offer whose salary is predicated on the lie would constitute fraud. Lying about your former compensation history is no different than lying about a prior criminal record, if the counterparty relies on the false assertion.




A very good point, but, and this gets a bit complex, they would have to prove that they relied upon on false information to decide to hire or pay you.

So Bob and Anna are equally qualified and currently paid 50k. They both apply for same job and Bob says he has a (fake) PhD and is paid 50k and anna does not lie about qualifications but says her base is 100k

Most of us would say Bob has committed an illegal act because the link between qualifications and hiring decision seems so clear. But there is a very weak link between previous salary and hiring decision, so how far must the company prove that it uses prior salary in hiring decisions? Just the fact that it asks? The fact it only offers prior plus 5%? That prior salary is used to rank CVs?


Unless current employer a) receives your permission to pull your tax return transcripts or b) receives your permission to contact your previous employer and you provide permission for previous employer to divulge said information, you will almost surely not be found out.

Disclaimer: Not a lawyer, not your lawyer, but fairly confident based on past experience with this over ~15 years.


you will almost surely not be found out.

... unless, like patio11, you decide to blog about your salary history at some point.

The problem with lies is that you need to remember what they were so that you don't contradict yourself later.


I'm flattered you responded to my comment cperciva!

patio11 is unusually (yet refreshingly) open with his financial information.

If you're going to blog about your intimate financial details, you should of course "have your ducks in a row".


I'm flattered you responded to my comment

Don't be -- I don't think there's any correlation between the quality of a comment and whether I respond to it. ;-)

If you're going to blog about your intimate financial details, you should of course "have your ducks in a row".

Right, but once you've lied about something it's impossible to put that particular duck back where it belongs.


I don't disagree, but sometimes lying is necessary.


You can triple-dog-dare an employer to fire you "with cause" from a role where you are performing well for lying about previous salary. This is a silly concern. It's just not going to happen.


You're assuming that employers are rational. Most of them aren't.

There are a bunch of jobs with ethical requirements so lying is probably going to cause problems.


In sny job where you deal with confidential or financial data - you would be unwise to try it.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: