Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Land the rocket on some flame-proof air bags. It doesn't have to land vertically does it? Let it fall over gently if need be.



The dang thing is a couple mm thick and ten stories tall. There's no "gentle" option available for tipping over. The solution is to land it right. It'll happen.


No flame-proof airbags are available on Mars.

AFAIK most of SpaceX's design decisions are based around this.


But can't the vehicle carry them to Mars? Kind of like the airbag system for one of the rovers, can't remember which one (Curiosity?)

Or even better, how about getting it to land sideways on purpose? I don't see how that would be more difficult than doing it upright.


Imagine the material that a coke can is made off.

Now imagine a cylinder made of that material 3-4 times wider than a barrel and 20-30ft high.

That's why you can't land them sideways they'd just crush themselves.


I guess you are right. It wouldn't make sense to make a rocket that can withstand vertical AND horizontal forces. That would be like launching a brick I guess.

Thanks for the pointer.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: