Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's funny that just today, before I found out about the glibc vulnerability, I reconsidered if I really want to upgrade my Ubuntu 10.04 mail and web servers to Ubuntu 14.04 LTS. I was triggered after reading some bad things about 14.04 [1]. I've looked at the M:Tier binpatches and package upgrades for OpenBSD, looked at FreeBSD, Debian with it's experimental LTS, but eventually I'm still in favor of the 5-year support for Ubuntu server.

I have bad experiences in upgrading production machines in-place, whether it is OpenBSD, Ubuntu or Debian and always install a new machine (vps) side-by-side which is really the only stress-free guaranteed way to go in my opinion. Having to do this only once every 5 years is really a lot nicer then at least once a year. The good security backports of Ubuntu, minimal breakage (auto-security upgrades at my Ubuntu servers have been working almost flawlessly [2]) are the least maintenance, stable and secure setup I can imagine.

OpenBSD having only one year of support, no binpatches of the kernel and having no stable security fixes of the packages are the reason I only use it with anything that can be done by the base system (backup host and nameserver). OpenSMTPd looks very promising, but I would need supported amavisd packages, same goes for httpd that needs php in my setup. Besides it's limited use, I still love OpenBSD and the mindset that stewards it. If only they had longer support and binpatches for kernel and packages :)

[1] https://tim.siosm.fr/blog/2014/04/25/why-not-ubuntu-14.04-lt...

[2] the mail config was overwritten once after an auto security update of dovecot in 10.04, quickly recovered it with etckeeper (/etc in git)



Thanks for the tip on etckeeper! I've been wanting something like that for a while.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: