Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> why vote? When democracy emerged in the U.S., the voting population was about 800,000. The current voting population is 206,000,000. The power of an individual's vote has decreased immensely.

I agree that the power to change the outcome of an election is minimal, roughly equal to every other voter.

Voting does much more than change election outcomes; it signals the electorate's priorities. Win or lose, every vote from your neighborhood, district, town, county, etc. signals that people there care, and pressures elected officials to pay attention to them. Every vote for your issues, win or lose, signals your priorities. Your representatives' jobs depend on pleasing voters. Democrats elected in districts where people vote for gun rights are not going to push gun control in Congress (and vice versa for Republicans). Counties where 75% vote will get politicians' attention and have their issues addressed; those where 30% vote will be overlooked.

And every non-vote in your neighborhood, district, town, county, etc. tells your elected officials that you don't care and that they can safely ignore you.




If what voters thinks matters, why is so much money spent on campaigns? Answering my own question, I would say that it is because votes can be bought.

Who is more powerful? Someone with $10M to spend on a campaign, or someone with the best political thinking who has no money to spend on a campaign?


> If what voters thinks matters, why is so much money spent on campaigns?

Hmmm... The obvious answer is: To persuade voters to think your way. But I suspect I misunderstand the question.

> Who is more powerful? Someone with $10M to spend on a campaign, or someone with the best political thinking who has no money to spend on a campaign?

Clearly the former. With $10M, you can persuade many voters to agree with you. But since that fits with my above post, I think I'm missing your point.

In the end, however they are formed, it's still voters' opinions (and actions) that matter.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: