While the conclusions in this book happen to be valid for the vast majority (i.e. somewhere between 95-99% of the population should stick to index investing), people often mis-apply the conclusions in this book to suggest that certain things are impossible, and that is clearly false and misleading.
There are people who invest and trade successfully, and they are not lucky outliers any more than a brain surgeon is a lucky outlier.
I once asked a guy who made his living off of trading stocks and futures how long would it take me to learn. His answer was sobering. If I made it my full time job for 3-5 years, I could learn to be marginally profitable, and with additional years of experience I could make enough to live off of. He guessed maybe 5-10 years of 40+ hours per week dedicated to trading, and even then, if I did not study the right things I could still fail. Contrast this with the average Joe trying his hand at investing, and of course they will fail. You can't dedicate 3-5 hours per week and expect to be a competent brain surgeon.
Using the same logic in this book, we could conclude that it's impossible for anyone to start a successful business. The message should be, it's really hard and takes a lot of work, and it takes a lot of knowledge about how to run a business, and it takes a high level of competency at some skill (coding, carpentry, whatever), and you have to be competent at communicating with others, and leading others, and not have personal baggage to draw your focus away from the business, and, well, you get the idea. It's hard, and it's not for everyone, but it's not impossible.
While the conclusions in this book happen to be valid for the vast majority (i.e. somewhere between 95-99% of the population should stick to index investing), people often mis-apply the conclusions in this book to suggest that certain things are impossible, and that is clearly false and misleading.
There are people who invest and trade successfully, and they are not lucky outliers any more than a brain surgeon is a lucky outlier.
I once asked a guy who made his living off of trading stocks and futures how long would it take me to learn. His answer was sobering. If I made it my full time job for 3-5 years, I could learn to be marginally profitable, and with additional years of experience I could make enough to live off of. He guessed maybe 5-10 years of 40+ hours per week dedicated to trading, and even then, if I did not study the right things I could still fail. Contrast this with the average Joe trying his hand at investing, and of course they will fail. You can't dedicate 3-5 hours per week and expect to be a competent brain surgeon.
Using the same logic in this book, we could conclude that it's impossible for anyone to start a successful business. The message should be, it's really hard and takes a lot of work, and it takes a lot of knowledge about how to run a business, and it takes a high level of competency at some skill (coding, carpentry, whatever), and you have to be competent at communicating with others, and leading others, and not have personal baggage to draw your focus away from the business, and, well, you get the idea. It's hard, and it's not for everyone, but it's not impossible.