Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The even better part is when you make assumptions about what you know about your friends and it turns out one of them is celiac and just hasn't had a biopsy to confirm. Making medical decisions for your friends without their knowledge is always a great idea.



You'll know if you're celiac -- "vague" and "nonspecific" "maybe feel slightly bloated" are not symptoms of the disease.

They are however specific to the latest hypochondriac food fad that's swept the nation and as numerous controlled studies on random non-celiac populations are starting demonstrate with Science, are treatment for disorders (NCGS) that don't even exist.

It appears that "gluten sensitivity" industry (an $11 billion dollar industry) is now about to run its course, so the next fads are starting to spin up, FODMAPs or Frutates or whatever is probably the next big thing. And guess what my prediction is going to be, all those people who complain of vague non-specific NCGS will start eating Gluten again without any complaint and completely forget about it, while simultaneously froggering over to FODMAP free diets or whatever to deal with their vague non-specific hypochondriac symptomologies.


> You'll know if you're celiac -- "vague" and "nonspecific" "maybe feel slightly bloated" are not symptoms of the disease.

No, that's not true. My daughter has celiac disease; she has a severe version, so we found this out when she was about 4 years old.

However, in later life my mother suffered from serious food sensitivity problems. She wasn't diagnosed with celiac because that was 15+ years ago. Given my daughter's medical history, I'd bet even odds that celiac was exactly what my mother had, even though the serious problems didn't occur until old age. There is a very strong genetic component to the disease. Wikipedia discusses this at length, but I'm certainly not qualified to know how accurate that information is.

So it's quite possible that with less severe celiac, people only have mild symptoms or only develop severe symptoms late in life.

Sorry to quote Wikipedia, they're hardly authoritative, but I think this is a reasonable summary[1]:

   People with milder coeliac disease may have
   symptoms that are much more subtle and occur
   in other organs than the bowel itself. It is
   also possible to have coeliac disease without
   any symptoms whatsoever. Many adults with
   subtle disease only have fatigue or anaemia.
Edit: just wanted to add that information in this field is changing rapidly. When I requested a DNA test for my daughter about 8 years ago, her gastroenterologist was reluctant. He was admittedly quite surprised when my daughter turned out to have the problem alleles. So it's all "relatively new" even for one of the "experts" in the 19th most populous MSA in the United States.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coeliac_disease




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: