I have to plug Hypothes.is [1] who are doing this in an open source and distributed fashion. They have quite a team and a lot of grant money to make it happen.

[1] http://hypothes.is/

There's also PeerLibrary.

What would be most interesting out of all this is a viable open annotation protocol, and an infinite number of federated sites that use it.

Hey whoever's building this -- please give me a shout. christianpbrink at gmail. If you haven't built it yet, maybe you don't need to, as I already have and may be interested in a partnership.

I wonder if they have a MVP for testing out yet, or if its a collection of emails to register the level of interest before the pilot is built?

Sounds similar to Diigo: https://www.diigo.com

Love the idea - thought of it 7+ years ago! Hope you guys succeed.

Nice in theory.