The fact that Special Relativity has meant different things to different people and that even most relativist professors have made statements that imply contradictory interpretations is well known and well documented.
http://worknotes.com/Physics/SpecialRelativity/TwinParadox/a...
Okay, I read some of the material on that site, and all it says to me is that (a) not everyone who has been exposed to Special Relativity understands it, and (b) some people think that if they don't understand something, it can't be true.
