Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I agree, but consider that it's on Nature.com and the expected audience. This was an entertaining read for those who have felt such frustration, but it's ultimately unhelpful as a published article.

I did appreciate the point about being proud to be bad at math. I think that attitude is damaging and probably deserves a (more reasoned) article of its own.



Except that those who are "proud to be bad at math" exude pride because they've given up, but don't want to feel like a failure. In other words, all attempts at math education have so far failed them, and they have succumbed to learned helplessness.

When people are consistently frustrated using your website, you'd normally look into the UX so that you can make a smoother experience. You then test to make sure your changes actually made your site better. Math and science education is no different, except that those in charge tend to treat it like the bad old UNIX days of "If it was hard to write, it should be hard to understand" and "RTFM".


> Except that those who are "proud to be bad at math" exude pride because they've given up, but don't want to feel like a failure.

I totally agree. What I'm saying is I'd love to read a more nuanced piece exploring this attitude including its causes and effects.


The odds are heavy that the doctors don't understand the math either https://www.mpib-berlin.mpg.de/en/media/2012/03/new-study-ph...

I used to think "if I could just punish/control other people the world would be so much better because I'm so smart." But then I went through puberty.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: