Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

When you are fundamentally running shell commands, using python/perl really don't make a lot of sense. Use the best tool for the job. Note that for my dayjob I write python almost fulltime, but if I'm almost exclusively running shell commands, I'll write a shell script. Just because you can do something one way doesn't necessarily mean I should.

See I'm of the opinion that if you need arrays and associative arrays, bash is the wrong tool for the job. If you have a recent bash it has both of those, just seems wrong in such a clunky language with awful scoping.



I write a lot of bash scripts, but lately I've been doing most of my shell interop in Ruby instead. Backticks are pretty good and I can munge things in easier ways than bash or Python. And with `ruby -n`, the script is invoked line-by-line--perfect for processing piped content.


Use the best tool for the job. If you don't know bash/bourne shell well, use ruby/perl/python/etc. I started out as a sysadmin years ago and know bourne shell/bash very very well. It is all about what works best for the problem.


Sure. And don't get me wrong, I write a lot of bash scripts. =) I think any logic beyond string replacement is probably edging out of where it's a good idea, if only because other people then have to read my stuff later, but it's totally fine for that. I'm saying more that I think Ruby (or Perl) make more sense than Python given the tools it provides.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: