I think the comparison is absolutely essential. I always want a guide to the resources about a topic so that I can find out where to look to learn the way I want to learn.
But the judgment is probably strong. Right now, my immediate reason to learn OCaml is because Types and Programming Languages uses it for its type checkers. For that purpose, I might just want quicker tutorials that don't cover the runtime. Ditto if my primary goal is to learn more about using types for good API design. On the other hand, if I learn and continue with the language, or want to put it into production, the runtime is essential. There's lots of use cases out there.
Yeah, I agree, I was probably too hard on LYAH. But, even if my goals didn't match your goals, I am hoping that the information I am giving you is sort of useful either way. The emphasis is really on the reasoning, rather than the conclusion.
But the judgment is probably strong. Right now, my immediate reason to learn OCaml is because Types and Programming Languages uses it for its type checkers. For that purpose, I might just want quicker tutorials that don't cover the runtime. Ditto if my primary goal is to learn more about using types for good API design. On the other hand, if I learn and continue with the language, or want to put it into production, the runtime is essential. There's lots of use cases out there.