Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I have just had this very issue directly as an electronic music producer.

Was flagged for my own original music NOT on a remix or anything that contained samples but an original jam I made with some classic Roland hardware; Roland SH-101, TR-909, and TR-606! Seems the algorithm they use to flag has many flaws and is automated with no one at the wheel to look at individual cases.

Not sure where soundcloud is going with this, because I pay for the service and replied to them to fix and have heard nothing in over a month.

Moved my song over to mixcloud. I am creating a music app for musicians called Memory Echo if anyone is interested in working together on something different but similar for musicians that are not signed.

Knew this day would come just didn't know when.

Cheers! Electronic Sleep



That's a much more legit complaint than the one in the source article, and as an electronic musician myself I can see how that would happen. Sadly Mixcloud has problems of its own, eg this, which I posted here the other day: http://support.mixcloud.com/customer/portal/articles/1595564...


I was so confused on what type of license would prevent me seeking a track. Luckily I can just google "download from mixcloud" and problem goes away.


Same thing happened to us, but with a couple of official remixes released on a sub-label of universal. The issue is that the content gets removed before you're able to verify it's yours.

I feel like they would have avoided a lot of negativity if they gave users a time window to verify before removal.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: