Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I'm not sure if you were insinuating that SE's fragmentation was a bad thing. If you are, SE actively fragment's itself for a reason. Watch Spolsky talk about it here: http://vimeo.com/37309773

Quora's non-fragmentation is it's ultimate downfall.

I'm all bull on SE and bear on Quora.




Im not sure yet if the SE fragmentation is a good thing or bad yet. From one perspective I see where they are coming from and why they are doing it. But in today's age of IT where the specialists is dead and people are more-or-less required to be an expert generalist it is very frustrating to use SE. I find myself more or less giving up when a question gets migrated to a SE Im not a 'member' of yet (they should really just make all users IDs members on all their sites whether people use them or not). Whether you are a webmaster, server admin, programmer, general PC user or just want to ask a general question about how SE works, I shouldn't need to go so many places. It's really 50-50 in my mind if they are doing a good thing or bad (and it probably doesnt matter in the end)

But I have never used Quora, so I know nothing about it beyond getting the blurred webpage when you are not a member there. Ill check out that video now.


K. How do you express those views? Are you buying SE shares via MicroVentures, etc.? How do you go short Quora?


I meant metaphorically. Both companies are capitalized privately.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: