Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Watching an uncontrolled drone strafe an overpass at street level and split power lines for a commuter train, really increases my sympathy toward those who want to regulate these.


We really should also regulate pigeons.


Pigeons usually do not have fast-spinning blades attached to them. I am not really for regulation, but these things can actually hurt people [1]. RC Helicopters (with one large, main rotor) have actually killed people [2].

Hobbyists must take great care to operate their drones safely, and companies should assume some liability for runaway situations like this if they ever result in injuries.

Warning, pictures of injuries:

[1a] https://www.google.com/search?q=quadrotor+injury&tbm=isch

[1b] https://www.google.com/search?q=multirotor+injury&tbm=isch

[2] RC helicopter fatalities: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2413231/Roman-Piroze...


So can people with knives or swords, or baseballs propelled by a bat. Anyway, I suspect that all of those quadcopter injuries occurred while the owner was setting up the quadcopter. Every story I've read (mostly from my frequent visits to RC hobby forums) is from people attempting to test functionality on a bench with the propellers on, or perhaps a few people who attempt to take off with their aircraft right at their feet. The RC helicopter death is a valid point, but that's the only RC aircraft related death I know of, and helis like his pretty much self-regulate because they're expensive, require mechanical knowledge to setup and maintain, and will mostly likely never get off the ground if flown by someone who doesn't know what they're doing.


>Pigeons usually do not have fast-spinning blades attached to them

BRB attaching circular saw to pigeon


Sure, everything has to be regulated; but how do you propose to regulate and then how do you propose to enforce those regulations?


I'll leave the specifics to the better informed, but certified 'kill-switches' and 'no-fly-zones' seem like obvious places to start.


DJI is massive player in the commercial drone space, so when regulations get written, you can bet DJI will be one of the corporations writing them.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: