Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Of course they are separable.

If you are buying a home to live in rather than an investment you can ride out the odd declining market.

Seems like people have a lot of 'once bitten, twice shy' syndrome when it comes to housing. Market corrections like 2008 are exceedingly rare. I am not saying prices go up forever like so many idiots did around that time, but if you buy in a non-volatile market, it is a pretty safe bet that your home price will at least retain much of its value.




There's no such thing as a "safe bet". If housing was a safe bet then significant amounts on money would feed into the housing money until it stopped being a safe bet. That's just basic market efficiency theory.

Most mortgages are typically 30+ years, based on historic data you're almost guaranteed to see a house price crash sometime over a 30 year period.

(Although it's important to remember that the future isn't necessarily going to reflect the past)


You are not understanding.

I am not saying it is a safe /investment/ I am saying it is a safe(ish) /value store/. There is a big difference.

Your comment is the equivalent of saying "Saving accounts are not a safe bet. If it were everyone would be putting money into savings accounts until it stopped being a safe bet."

You have to pay so much to have a roof over your head whether it is through rent or through ownership. Even if a house is a loser, investment wise, it can be a winner value-store wise.

Now, you can totally mess that up by buying a home at the peak of a bubble and watch it tumble to near worthlessness, no doubt. But that is not the situation 99.999% of potential homeowners face.


It's safe-ish /as long as you continue to live there/. If you ever need to move for whatever reason you're back to the mercies of whatever market cycle happens to be in force.


That's true. And the real risk in buying a primary residence is in churn costs which are relatively huge and take years to make up.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: