Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I suspect that this is the result of incompetence on their part rather than an actual intent to log private data. Either way though, obviously not good.



I do understand, that most seemingly malicious intend has its roots in incompetence.

In an answer to German press-inquiries, LG states, that the feature will stay. The only thing, they will change is, that disabling the feature really disables it. They stated, that this was a bug. And I actually believe this. I did not allege, it was malicious intend.

My real argument was, that I am more then happy, to pay good money for a good TV. But that I see no reason, why I should have to pay with my data as well (not being informed on that by the way, when buying this TV) and with this feature being enabled by default.

Sidenote: They told the German press, that the receiving server dropped the information, when the feature was disabled. They never told anyone, how the server should have been able to do that. As far, as I could see, the requests did not change, when deactivating that feature.


Hi! Friendly native English speaker here. Just a tip, your posts read as very disjointed because you are using the comma so often! You can think of the comma as representing a pause in speech. Re-read your post, taking a pause every time you encounter a comma and you'll see how disjointed it feels. You are making good points, but I found your posts difficult to read because of this issue.


Thanks a lot for your tip. I know that the comma is some form of tick for me. Will try to better myself.

Greetings from Germany.


"Any sufficiently advanced incompetence is indistinguishable from malice"


I'm definitely going to have to remember that one for later.


> why I should have to pay with my data as well (not being informed on that by the way, when buying this TV)

You were probably informed, somewhere between page 1 and 514 in the EULA.


Nah. Consumers are meat. Product to be packaged and sold in bulk. Nothing personal, but the corporate masters just don't care that much.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: