Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Installing lastpass on every machine I happen to stroll by and want to use isn't the cleanest of solutions... and I shouldn't have to trust my keys to one closed, proprietary application. With a standard protocol at least I'd have a choice about my client.

There are also peripheral issues with password databases, like the fact that they make the mere fact that you're using one transparent to anyone investigating your activities.




You can ofcourse log in to lastpass.com on any other machine you are sure doesn't have a keylogger (well they provide virtual keyboard also if thats the case).

But ofcourse, that's matter of trust, even when they say that data is encrypted client side and they store only blob of gibberish. However I feel so relieved by using LastPass - not having to worry about remembering yet another password.


...(well they provide virtual keyboard also if thats the case).

If you assume a key logger, you should also assume a mouse logger that captures a partial screenshot for every mouse click, as well as the possibility of capturing the contents of password fields (malware in the Windows 9x era would iterate through all OS widgets to find password fields and save their contents).


Right, but even if we can check all the boxes and trust LP, there's still the practical matter of getting everyone to use it. Generally it's going to be easier to convince users to use something that's built-in rather than 3rd party, right?

And one solution, whether it's backdoored or not, is still one target for bad actors to focus on (viruses, spoofing, etc).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: