Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Firstly, your comment is not what I called foolish. I was referring to the original act. Secondly, I'm not raging at all. I'm quite calm. That is what I'm actually asking for. Calmness.

With regards to driving not being related because of it 'having regulations', RC model plane flying has regulations too. Ones I abide by. You say it needs to be regulated. Guess what? It is. I've even talked to my local ranger about the regulations.

I think if you look at it you're actually over reacting a little. If you are worried about "copter cut someone's head off", what about someone who chops someone's head off without first getting "a permit"? What will you do then? There will always be foolish people doing foolish things. And there are laws and consequences.

Have you actually looked at your local regulations regarding RC plane flying?




if I did seem over reacted, my apology.

Let's refine restriction then.

This news is probably not too old for some local people.

http://blogs.wsj.com/metropolis/2013/09/05/remote-control-he...

http://www.ntv7.com.my/7edition/local-en/FREAK_ACCIDENT_18_M...

In both accident, a giant, powerful RC aircraft killed people. Is this the kind we should ban? From the veteran perspective, how do we go about regulating these? Should these be regulated?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SpveweAqGYM

http://www.rcuniverse.com/forum/rc-helicopter-general-discus...

Can these be flying in the city? In a small park?

Even for a tiny toy aircraft, it could go wild and hit pedestrian, or a moving vehicle and might cause some unnecessary injury.


Wow. Those stories are shocking! I notice they're both helicopters. I've always found quads and helis scary (dangerous combined with difficult to fly) and I fly RC planes exclusively. The regulations need to recognise both ends of the continuum. The regulations applying to a high powered RC model helicopter should be quite different to those that apply to something like a parkzone mini vapor. But both are considered RC aircraft.

The regulations are outdated too. But not only in the high-powered end, but also the low powered and new micro end. I am not allowed to fly the mini vapor (or any other RC aircraft) in any park in my electorate. But there are many of small park flyers that are very safe.

As is often the case, the law struggles to keep up with the pace of technological change. It's really modern lipo battery tech that has enabled this change. Both at the high end, with large craft using 12 cell lipo batteries (50 Volts and capable of delivering hundreds of Amps for short periods), and at the low end with minture 1 and 2 cell micro lipos.

Regulations could have categories based in part apon things like:

- peak power output of battery/motor system

- material of craft's construction (EPO foam vs balsa or even aluminium)

- size, orientation and exposure of propellors and blades (ducted fans vs multiple large horitonal rotors)

- weight of aircraft

- top speed of aircraft




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: