Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

But an Instagram has a high risk of failure whereas a transportation infrastructure is a very low-risk investment. The Hyperloop would be better compared with a huge Internet infrastructure like Google Search than with Instagram.



> transportation infrastructure is a very low-risk investment.

That's a good one. Building out a technology that has never been proven in a lab, let alone at production scale, in an industry where 2x cost overruns are inevitable and 10x not uncommon, that is dominated by government spending and not private capital for infrastructure, you consider the hyperloop a low-risk investment.

It might work, despite the skepticism, but there is no sense in which it can be considered low-risk.


Yes, I was talking about expensive infrastructures in general. It would be crazy to start building the Hyperloop before some working prototypes have proven that it works. But the high-speed train has low risks of loosing money if highways and airlines are saturated (i.e. if the demand is there, which can be predicted by studies).




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: