Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The implicit synchronization happens at the point the child thread is started, regardless of when it was allocated. Perhaps it was already started prior to the initialization, in which case some form of explicit synchronization would be required to ensure visibility.

FYI, the relevant section of the JLS is 17.4.4: "An action that starts a thread synchronizes-with the first action in the thread it starts." [1].

[1] http://docs.oracle.com/javase/specs/jls/se7/html/jls-17.html...




This sounds more like what we experienced:

> The write of the default value (zero, false or null) to each variable synchronizes-with the first action in every thread. Although it may seem a little strange to write a default value to a variable before the object containing the variable is allocated, conceptually every object is created at the start of the program with its default initialized values.

I can't get that to jibe in my memory though against:

> The final action in a thread T1 synchronizes-with any action in another thread T2 that detects that T1 has terminated.

> T2 may accomplish this by calling T1.isAlive() or T1.join().

If we were looking into the threads, it would have been obvious that we should wait for the thread to finish before expecting to find a completed value in it other than the default. That's not what happened.

It's unfortunate that I didn't get a copy of the code in question, because it was a genuine idiosyncrasy in Java and by the time I got around to asking my friend for a copy, he had already rewritten his code in a different way that didn't hit the same bug.

Didn't use revision control, got his degree didn't care to repeat the same miserable exercises, now probably hacking ruby in his day job like me (except I promise I'm using revision control.)


I can guarantee you the class was not offered the option of using Java 7. I'll take your word for it if you say this is not a new feature, but I'm sure the story went just about how I've laid it out.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: