Agreed. Even though the site says "requires a credit card" as some type of security measure, it doesn't secure anything. What are the chances that if your locked item is opened, you would trace the theft back to this service to notify them?
Slim. You'd have to catch the perpetrator first and then figure out how he got a key.
99.99999% of people don't even know a service like this exists let alone to check if their house key was duplicated there before it got robbed.
In the U.S., the main deterrent against robbery is jail time. Most houses can be broken into with an elbow. Locks prevent silent entry and make it slightly harder to break in, they don't secure anything.
This. Locks keep honest thieves out. I don't know of any house that I couldn't gain entry into in a few minutes, without damaging anything, including my own.
No, it's often much easier than that. I do live in a pretty quiet neighborhood, but that's not what I meant either. There are a couple of things. One is that people tend to be vigilant WRT their home's primary access, but pay less attention to side-doors, back-doors, garage-doors, and windows. So you can often find one of these left unsecured. The second is that the latches on windows are notoriously bad WRT their ability to stay closed. They can often be dislodged by just bumping them gently while applying pressure in the right place, even when installed correctly. If they were installed incorrectly, or just carelessly, or if the house has "settled" windows can be even easier to defeat. Another weakness of windows is the glazing, sometimes it just slips out, or can be easily pried loose, sometimes it takes a screwdriver. Until very recently, little attention seems to have been paid to the security of windows in residential construction. There are a few other more-foolproof entry methods that I know that do little or no damage, but they aren't the sort of thing that a burglar would do.
PS I learned most of this at Texas Fireman's Training Academy (and just paying attention to my surroundings), in case you're wondering.
Slim. You'd have to catch the perpetrator first and then figure out how he got a key.
99.99999% of people don't even know a service like this exists let alone to check if their house key was duplicated there before it got robbed.