Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

How is race more fine-grained than the socioeconomic status of individual schools?



It's not; the socioeconomic data is just hard for schools to get.


Really? I understand the difficulty in getting data for individual students, but for the areas that a school serves, I figured that there was some sort of public demographic data for them.

If it is, than they could simply use past test scores, giving a curve for schools that have done the worst in past years.


Why would you expect the socioeconomic status of all students at a school to be the same?


Assuming five races: Given that there are more than five schools, than using a school's past score performance or socioeconomic status is going to be closer to their individual score than the aggregate for their race.

tl;dr School is finer grained than race because there are more schools than races.


That only works when you are able to control for all other factors.


Because school districts in the US are shockingly segregated by both race and income.


A consequence of school funding being based entirely on local property taxes.


And let's face it: also some of our own segregationist instincts. Even liberal San Francisco recently abandoned its eminently egalitarian policy of mixing up the public school population by not basing assignments on neighborhood. I'm not the only progressive who cringes at the thought of not being able to buy my daughter into a particular type of school district.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: