Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Europe has plenty of shale gas but refuses to exploit it. Nuclear was stopped or even dismantled. There is such a lack of strategic thinking that at some point the only logical conclusion is that we like to suffer and to lose.


> at some point the only logical conclusion is that we like to suffer and to lose.

Or that our political and media class are captured...


> Or that our political and media class are captured...

Yes, obviously that's the case, however it goes beyond that. I still vividly remember how in high school they taught us persistently how bad nuclear power is for the environment. And TBH for a very long time, I actually believed it. A lot of people in Germany never stopped believing it. At this point we have to admit to ourselves that the "Green"'s are a political ideology with good slogans, but ultimately contrary to their own messaging it is: pro-war, anti-worker, anti-independence, and generally just a basket to capture anti-empire sentiment to redirect them towards supporting it.


> There is such a lack of strategic thinking

Is a result of decades of russian effort


Nuclear was stopped? Look at France.


The nuclear programme was effectively stopped in France and it is struggling to be revived.

As things stand now it won't be able to compensate for the closure of older reactors.


> The nuclear programme was effectively stopped in France and it is struggling to be revived.

You're describing France from 2010 to 2020, not today.


Since 2020 it is struggling to revive its nuclear programme. Lots of fancy plans and announcements but let's see how reality unfolds.

New operational reactor in 2024 was the first in 25 years so hardly "since 2010"...


Under Hollande, France swung in an anti-nuclear direction, with plans to reduce nuclear power down to 50 percent of the energy mix, fuelled by the post-Fukushima panic. When Emmanuel Macron took power in 2017, he was still committed to this target and closed down Fessenheim in 2020, despite calls from pro-nuclear groups to extend its life.

Following the surge in energy prices triggered by the Ukraine War, France reversed course yet again.


Again, dragging up the past. Fine, let's exclude 2020. 2021-2022 was more of a turning point. Your comment doesn't refute my point, a point which does refute the point I was replying to.


I would really recommend listening to discussion with Mark Nelson, managing director of Radiant Energy Group, about the state of the French nuclear power industry. "Something's Rotten with French Nuclear" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=isgu-VrD0oM


You have not refuted anything. I have replied to your claims... why you would want to deny reality? Strange.

In addition, nuclear energy policy and developments is measured in decades not sungle years. My point remains. France is struggling to revive its nuclear energy programme...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: