Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Show HN: Network Monitor – a GUI to spot anomalous connections on your Linux
144 points by grigio 1 day ago | hide | past | favorite | 52 comments
A real-time network connection monitoring tool built with Rust and GTK4, displaying active connections with live I/O statistics in a modern graphical interface. https://github.com/grigio/network-monitor




I see that you're parsing `ss` output in 'src/services/network.rs' (L22-L31) [1]. I find this to be a rather shaky foundation as any future drift or deviation in the `ss` utility's output could potentially yield unforeseen consequences.

I'm vaguely aware that there are crates available in the Rust ecosystem for interrogating and manipulating sockets much more directly as well as high level abstractions for all things netlink (read: AF_NETLINK). Is wielding Rust's socket/netlink libraries unsuitable in some way, or was it merely deemed out of the design scope?

Very cool project, please keep going!

[1] https://github.com/grigio/network-monitor/blob/master/src/se...


I tried to do the most simple thing, thanks for the feedback

maybe consider support for the opensnitch ebpf backend?

Fantastic, more of this. I don't know if I'm just missing it or what, but I'd love a GUI thing that showed all the devices on my network maybe even with a graph view.

I'm using an Eero router out of laziness and even it has some features here that I'd like to see more of in polished "home-user" style network tools; especially since it seems as if more are getting into the "homelab"/"selfhosted" thing.


Do you mean something like nmap's network topolgy view? https://nmap.org/book/zenmap-topology.html

Just for visualizing network topology on Linux, there's a lot of tools.


That's impossible to do reliably without using agents, SNMP, or some other kind of communication protocol that you'll have to set up on each device. If you're ok with that, use SNMP. If you want topology, you'll have to have an agent that logs into all your networking gear and parses the configs.

Nice work!

I do want to say, I don't like having to rely on scraping ss output. But that's not a comment on this project - I have done the exact same thing. It just proved to be the most expedient way given the constraints I was under. I suspect there is a lot of devops and CI/CD code out there that relies on the output format of ss. My concern is that parsing text intended for human readability and not machine processing is brittle and prone to failure due to unforeseen circumstances, or a package upgrade that changes the behavior.



I was going to say the same thing.

I really like the eBPF approach as pointed out to by the other comments. I feel like this is the ideal approach, please correct me if I'm wrong.

A callback based approach as opposed to (constantly) polling the output of some command is ideal.


Cool project, I wish we had more GUIs for these OS functions. How was your experience with GTK4 and Rust?

And it's a bit sad that in the year of our lord 2025, the best way to get such fundamental information is by using regexes to parse a table[1], generated by a 6000-line C program[2], which is verified by (I hope I'm wrong!) a tiny test suite[3]. OSQuery[4] is also pretty cool, but it builds upon this fragile stack.

That's something I miss from Windows, at least PowerShell has built-in commands that give you structured output.

[1] https://github.com/grigio/network-monitor/blob/9dc470553bfdd...

[2] https://github.com/iproute2/iproute2/blob/main/misc/ss.c

[3] https://github.com/iproute2/iproute2/blob/main/testsuite/tes...

[4] https://osquery.io/


I am in the process of building myself a cross platform GUI for network monitoring.

Simply because I need one for non-critical stuff and things like uptime robot are enterprise geared and too expensive for me to entertain.

I wish there was an uptime robot for like 25 cents a monitor a month.


Uptime Kuma is FOSS, not sure if it is missing any features you might be expecting. Very easy to set up as well.

https://github.com/louislam/uptime-kuma


> It's a bit sad that [we're parsing output] ... generated by a 6000-line C program[2] ...

> That's something I miss from Windows, at least PowerShell has built-in commands that give you structured output.

It sure is something to disparagingly point to the LoC of 'ss' in one sentence, then pine for both PowerShell and the Windows infrastructure that supports it in the next.

You mentioned processing the output with regexes. That's definitely a code smell, but this is one line of the data from the 'ss' command in question, with fancily-aligned header line included, but with vast tracts of whitespace removed. The regex you pointed out is processing the column whose comma-separated data is enclosed in parens:

  Netid State     Recv-Q Send-Q  Local Address:Port  Peer Address:Port Process                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              
  tcp   LISTEN    0      666              [::]:22            [::]:*     users:(("sshd",pid=1337,fd=7)) ino:1338 sk:2024 cgroup:/openrc.sshd v6only:1 <->                         

They definitely didn't have to use a regex to process that, but chose to.

You could argue that a system that let you write client code that goes something like

    socket[i].process.users[0].cmd, socket[i].process.users[0].pid, socket[i].process.users[0].fd
is superior to one that requires writing something that makes use of the moral equivalent of 'cut'. I'd argue two things, one of them informed by my professional experience with PowerShell

1) What happens when the "structured" data you rely on changes shape? When that system that produces that "structured" data changes 'users' to 'user_list', 'cmd' to 'local_command', or deletes 'process' and moves 'users' up into its place, you're just as screwed as if 'ss' changed its output format in a way that wasn't backwards-compatible.

2) The core Microsoft tools might all produce "structured" data, but -in my professional experience- so, very, very little "community-provided" PowerShell code does. Why? I don't know for sure, but probably because it's notably more difficult to make a script or library produce that sort of data than it is to just emit regularly-formatted text.


The problem of data changing shape can happen regardless, but with text you have the added danger of escaping characters and ambiguities. Not to mention there are ad-hoc text formats for each and every tool, which can change from one version to another.

And you're right, PowerShell is far from perfect. I miss some of its design goals, not the whole thing.


First, a praise: Thank you for using native desktop UI, not some web framework and shipping additional browser along. And a bit of critique: Main screenshot should be bigger, and present the main view of the application. Ability to switch light/dark mode comes by default and target audience is more likely to see what data application displays and how.

Cool project! As a more advanced form, I think it should be possible to get all this information via eBPF rather than ss output and scraping /proc.

Food for thought!



The OP's project shows process names, which I do not see in this program.

BTW: This is also a TUI - much preferred !

Nice but it feels too much AI slop

eBPF doesn't work on locked down kernels (stock kernels in Secure Boot mode).

I think this is a great point, eBPF is cool but probably less popular than ss

eBPF is restricted when booted in a SB environment, but it's not nonfunctional. The default config puts the kernel into "integrity" mode of Kernel Lockdown, which reduces scope of access and enforces read-only usage.

Whether or not the specific functions needed to replicate this tool are impacted is beyond my knowledge.


I wish Linux had two more things:

- https://github.com/winsiderss/systeminformer power-user process explorer

- something akin windows system monitor, gnome's needs an upgrade


Thanks especially for using GTK with Rust to do this. We need to keep desktop Linux GUI libraries alive and viable (as an alterative to Web site GUI frameworks, Electron apps with Web frameworks, and proprietary mobile app platforms).

Though I was let down last week when I ported a TUI to GTK4 and found out that even a hello world gtk4.h C app uses 200mb RAM.

I haven’t tried it yet but I believe Qt will weigh around the same.

The TUI I ported uses <8mb RAM so I kinda lost interest in the GUI endeavor for my tools since I like to have one running in each project workspace.


> Though I was let down last week when I ported a TUI to GTK4 and found out that even a hello world gtk4.h C app uses 200mb RAM.

Bit of a rant I wanted to share here:

I've seen the same happened on zenity (a GUI dialog utility for shell scripts) since they migrated from GTK3 into GTK4.

Now zenity took almost 2 seconds to launch instead of .5 to a second when they still used GTK3.

This might be an issue on both libadwaita and GTK4 itself.

Both pavucontrol (which uses GTK4 but not libadwaita, at least for now) and even a simple dialog in zenity (GTK4+libadwaita) consumed over 100 MiB of memory according to btop measurement, while both thunar and engrampa, which is both GTK3 apps, only consumed half the amount of memory usage (about 50 MiB according to btop).

However, I've noticed that zenity, GNOME apps, and other apps that uses libadwaita took longer to launch compared to apps that only used GTK4 (pavucontrol), which launched as fast as other GTK3 apps does.


Hmm, maybe looking at btop memory usage is too naive.

I'm not very knowledgeable here, but apparently that includes the memory of libraries that other gtk4 apps would share.

$ awk '/Private/ {p+=$2} /Pss/ {s+=$2} END {print "Private:", p, "kB | PSS:", s, "kB"}' /proc/$(pgrep -x hello)/smaps

Private: 66172 kB | PSS: 129593 kB

That would suggest that the actual gtk4 hello world app process is 66mb, and the 130mb of shared libs would get amortized across other gtk4 apps?

I'll look into it further.


Update: It turns out that in GTK4, half of the memory usage were dedicated to OpenGL hardware rendering alone.

Using GSK_RENDERER=cairo almost halved the memory usage of most GTK4 apps, but it doesn't fix the startup time.


That screenshot / video on README page is mostly unreadable. Can't get anything out of it.

Same for me.

What info does it show more than a:

"netstat -tulpn"

Wrote myself a script years ago that basically loops netstat -tulpn watch like for the same purpose - just wondering if your tool shows me more than that.


modern graphical interface, for a start

I was asking which information it shows not what output it uses to display that information....

This app is clearly a demonstration of GTK4's light/dark transition animation. Looks like it works perfectly to me!

Come on, now. You can see that it supports today’s most critical feature: it has dark mode and light mode.

/s


If you live in the terminal it's all dark mode*

* unless you are one of those weirdo's who has a black on white terminal in which case you should be on a watch list (/s in case wasn't immediately obvious).


I've been there since the DOS days when it was all dark mode, green phosphor characters on a black CRT. I was there when amber monitors were the new thing. (I still love sunglasses with brown lenses.) And I watched the early Apple computers with graphics and black-characters-on-white display style that has been the rage ever since... well since the recent new thing being dark mode.

It reminds me of fashion trends, miniskirts then maxis, up and down past the knee like tides.

Fads, that's the word.


I am exactly that kind of weirdo, but then again I’ve been reading black on white books for my entire life and I never thought to complain about it.

This shows only the contents of /proc fs, right?

If you want realtime connection details, eBPF and XDP allow much more insights for that, as you can also parse network protocol payloads and implement adapters for each network protocol.


Nice work. I’ve been writing an app using the same stack. The gtk-rs bindings are actually pretty productive once you get used to it! And it’s so fast.

The code is partly refined AI generated slop and the UX is lacking. The functionality is very basic and needs to be more thoroughly tested. This type of project is half a work day tops for a senior+ dev to create with agentic coding.

May I ask how you made the determination that network-monitor is "partly refined AI generated slop"?

The mindless code comments are a dead giveaway. It's always the same pattern of: "a thing" <--- here is a thing Generally a dev would clean these up, but when they don't it's a major red flag to me that it's just unreviewed vibe coded slop.

I came to this conclusion as well. The README gives off some vibes but the sheer volume and writing style of the code comments is what really sells it for me. For example:

https://github.com/grigio/network-monitor/blob/9dc470553bfdd...

    // Enhanced styling with column-specific classes and alignment
This sort of marketing-speak isn't what people typically put in their code, LLMs love buzzwords. It's not just this, it's everything, but hopefully you get what I mean.

Submitted a pull request for MacOS Support - please approve. Tnx!

On a first look: The same as the shell tool nethogs, just with a GUI

So nethogs, but with a gui?

eBPF/XDP is nice and hard to use. Packet capture is so common that I wish that there were a simpler way like pcap.


Is there a version of this for the CLI?

bandwhich[0] is a recent one I'm familiar with

[0] https://github.com/imsnif/bandwhich


Unfortunate to see this project in passive maintenance! Hope the get the required funding/human power.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: