Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It was straight up co-sponsored by very nearly a majority of Senate Republicans (18 out of 42 at the time). It's hard to say a "vast majority of R's didn't support it". Though recently Republicans have been trying to distance themselves from it because it doesn't make their reaction to the ACA look great. There's a lot of rewriting of history.

Yes it didn't get debated, but the formal debate stage of a bill is pretty late in the process these days. It's been theater at best for at least a century. The actual debating happens at the stage the HEART Act got to.

It got dropped because the Republicans won congress in the midterms and didn't actually want to change anything about health care; the HEART act was just what they came up with as a proposal if they were to be forced.





It got dropped because the Republicans won congress in the midterms and didn't actually want to change anything about health care;

Right? So Republicans did not support it, or want it. It was just part of the Clinton Plan politics and negotiation. When Clinton failed, HEART totally disappeared.

recently Republicans have been trying to distance themselves from it

Of the 18 Republicans who co-sponsored it, none are still in politics, 14 of the 18 are now dead. Republicans today have literally nothing to do with it. It is getting silly to say a Republican today has any connection or responsibility for this proposal that never even came close to a vote, and not one current Republican has any connection to.


> Right? So Republicans did not support it, or want it. It was just part of the Clinton Plan politics and negotiation. When Clinton failed, HEART totally disappeared.

The ideal Republican plan was to have no healthcare reform. When faced with the proposition that no reform would cease to be tolerated, this was absolutely the Republican plan for health care reform, broadly supported by Republican leadership.

> Of the 18 Republicans who co-sponsored it, none are still in politics, 14 of the 18 are now dead. Republicans today have literally nothing to do with it. It is getting silly to say a Republican today has any connection or responsibility for this proposal that never even came close to a vote, and not one current Republican has any connection to.

They still mostly existed in politics at the passing of the ACA and the initial push back from the Republicans. Both the HEART Act and the ACA existed within the US's Sixth Political System.



None of that changes that it wasn’t what they wanted, it was what they were forced to put forward or else accept something even less palatable.

To claim they wanted that bill is entirely deceptive.


They wanted no reform. When they were politically required to put up literally any alternative, this was absolutely their proposal.



Consider applying for YC's Winter 2026 batch! Applications are open till Nov 10

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: