Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's your moral duty to avoid paying tax, if you're an American.


Given that America is a democracy, it would appear that a majority of Americans do not share your morals, so on the contrary it is your moral duty to pay your taxes.


Fun fact: precisely nobody who voted to elect the congresspeople who voted for the income tax amendment are alive today.

It’s a big stretch to assume that the current tax regime is related in any way to the will of the group of people who are currently subjected to it.


It's debatable that we're a democracy.


I would bet that in aggregate, more than half the taxes you pay go to your state, or some local polity smaller than state. Local political entities (county, city, town) are absolutely democracies and also have the maximum amount of actual impact on your life. The federal government is mostly irrelevant.

By avoiding paying taxes, you first and foremost damage the community you live in.


I don't know if I would agree with that take taken by itself without qualifiers. "if you're American" is doing some lifting but could mean anything. But otherwise I kind of agree, the average American is getting fleeced while the ultra wealthy are avoiding massive tax costs while benefiting the most from state infrastructure and economic policy.


No taxation without representation, so if your Congresscritter declares they don't represent you (because you identify as the opposite party and therefore are the enemy) then you have no responsibility to pay tax, a uniquely American sensibility

Of course the legal and ethical way to perform a tax protest is to simply have so little income that you don't owe them a thing


> Of course the legal and ethical way to perform a tax protest is to simply have so little income that you don't owe them a thing

That's the way it works. If you're really wealthy your team of accountants can find all sorts of ways to hide income and reduce it to zero or less. The more money you have coming in the less income you have to report, until the government you bought fair and square ends up owing you. Taxation is wonderful extra teat at which to suckle.


Uh? What? Care to explain?

I know it's considered a sport but a moral duty?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: