Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Most of my hard science contacts (physics, biology etc) from my days in student government have moved to Bluesky. Newer academics seem to be starting out there and skipping Twitter entirely.

If you have heard of Metcalfe's Law, you'll understand why this is not good for Twitter long term.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metcalfe's_law





So Bluesky for academia and X for tech and everyone else. I don’t think X is in trouble.

Scientist tend to form their own closed communities anyway.


It's like internet media is reaching a new level of maturity in that it is bifurcating into the tabloids and the serious magazines, like printed media was before.

In your analogy I suppose bluesky is the serious one? Have you spent any amount of time there?

They have the scientific community, so that's the direction they could be trending. But this is of course not settled yet.

>Scientist tend to form their own closed communities anyway.

Do you have a source for that?


> X for tech

SaaS, maybe. Tech, absolutely not.


[flagged]


>Well, they don’t like being challenged.

who is "they"


The BlueSky “scientific” community.

If they can’t withstand the pressure of actual public interaction, their research isn’t worth legitimizing.


Thankfully X isn't any more of an indicator of the "actual public" than bluesky

Unfortunately, when the silent majority stay... silent, their opinions go unmeasured and the vocal minority becomes "the public".

[flagged]


No, it’s because they’d rather talk to intelligent humans. X is populated by idiots and bots these days

This reads like a flippant comment, but I believe it is actually entirely accurate. It could be stated less harshly, but it's true.

So basically the usual BlueSky hugbox refrain.

Since covid much of the biological academic people on twitter were getting violent threats from anti-vaxxers and anyone angry about science contradicting the proclamations of their deal leader Trump.

Why would anyone with half a brain stay to experience that?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: