Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I think you might be getting carried away here.

Apple really hasn't "invented" anything. What they HAVE done is apply a keen sense of design and an obsessive focus on execution to a segment of a very diverse industry.

I think it goes without saying that Apple has had serious problems over its lifetime and there isn't a guarantee that they wont find themselves in that predicament again. My first computer was an Apple (//c, natch) and I can tell you that they nearly did themselves in a couple of times while IBM/Microsoft were leading the way.

Sic Transit Gloria.




I didn't say Apple invented the personal computer, or the portable music player, or the smartphone. What they did, and did very skillfully, was to appropriate the ideas and make a product so unique that it redefines the market around it. This is stealing the idea rather than merely copying it.

It's most interesting that the biggest problems Apple faced were when it was trying to copy the IBM PC by building dozens of different Mac models with expansion slots.


Uh, I think you're missing the part where Apple didn't copy or steal the Windows OS design and fell far behind in operating systems.

Or when they forgot about developers and let MSFT gain 90% of the market.

Or: Lisa. The Apple ///. Etc etc etc.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: