Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That's interesting, the few times I tried playing with whisper, I had the impression that YouTube style videos or random cellphone videos was something it did particularly bad with (compared to movies). My guess at the time was that most of the training material might be sub titles and raw screen plays.

The videos I tried to transcribe were also Mandarin Chinese, using whisper-large-v3. Besides the usual complaints that it would phonetically "mishear" things and generate nonsense, it was still surprisingly good, compared to other software I played around with.

That said, it would often invent names for the speakers and prefix their lines, or randomly switch between simplified and traditional Chinese. For the videos I tested, intermittent silence would often result in repeating the last line several times, or occasionally, it would insert direction cues (in English for some reason). I've never seen credits or anything like that.

In one video I transcribed, somebody had a cold and was sniffling. Whisper decided the person was crying (transcribed as "* crying *", a cough was turned into "* door closing *"). It then transcribed the next line as something quite unfriendly. It didn't do that anymore after I cut the sniffling out (but then the output switched back to traditional Chinese again).



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: