Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I addressed the "Bob could have saved that photo" point: "although you could theoretically save every photo and update anyone ever lets you see on Facebook, it would be difficult enough that in practice no one does." Facebook has a sane default of not saving everything that you view on your computer. Yes, maybe someone saved one or two photos, but they probably don't have them all.

OTR is pointless for a medium that's mostly about photo sharing. For the Facebook use case, what's far more important than crypto is the set of social norms the site establishes via what's easy to do (share) and what's hard, e.g., archiving everything your friends share as it comes in. Not only would that be tricky to do without getting detected as a bot, but 99.9% of users would never think to try it. This problem is inherently more tractable with a distributed system, and that could be bad.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: