Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> NASA did test receiving weak GPS signals on the moon with LRO in 2023.

I doubt very much that the position of the ISS in the article is being sent from the ISS at real time. It's more likely calculated using NORAD / Celestrak orbital elements plus orbital calculations.

I remember having a Windows desktop app to show the satellites locations, I'd have to download those text files to keep the information accurate. For the information beyond the snapshot, the app has to calculate distance and trajectory to estimate "If NORAD said it was here at this point in time, and heading that way with that speed, then right now it should be around here.". A bit like "If a train left Chicago 5 hours ago going 60 mph, where is it now?".

Nowadays it's all online of course: https://in-the-sky.org/satmap_worldmap.php .



> doubt very much that the position of the ISS in the article is being sent from the ISS at real time. It's more likely calculated using NORAD / Celestrak orbital elements plus orbital calculations.

Yes, this is how the referenced site knows the approximate position of the ISS via TLEs. TLEs are updated regularly for space objects


That doesn't matter for the problem at hand though. You can calculate the current GPS coordinates from any TLE, even if they aren't derived from GPS measurements but from Satellite Laser Ranging or some other method.


You can derive Lat and Lon and Altitude on Earth. Thats the one point of the TLEs. But they aren’t GPS derived coordinates.


Yes, but you don't need GPS derived coordinates for the DNS LOC entry.


Correct because the site referenced uses N2YO which is using NASA provided TLEs which some backend that provides an API. GPS and TLEs are not the same.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: