Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Ill bet he just opens every link in a new tab and uses tabs as readme-later list and navigation history. Both usecases are better served differently.

In general there is lots of overlap between tabs/tabgroups/bookmarks/history/readmelater/systemtaskbar/sessionrecovery.

Most people need all use cases but pick one or two features and emulate the rest themselves. Most tab related firefox plugins essentially duplicate functionality already present on top of the tab system.

For example: hierarchical tabs on the left with tab recovery is identical to having a bookmark list on the left.

It is my opinion that these concepts should all merge, preferbly at the desktop shell level. Ubuntu is movng is this direction, but they add this functionality on top of all the existing functionality. We can only hope that they will in the future consolidate all the overlap.




> Both usecases are better served differently.

They're really not. Not with any alternatives I've found, anyway. Tabs aren't just navigation history; they're curated, temporary history. Unworthy of the permanence of bookmarking, yet too important to regulate to the dense, rapid flow of history.

I use Pocket and Delicious to keep things in check, but they don't help as much I'd like. The most effective tab management tool for me has been Firefox's tab candy/expose feature. It's much easier to get an overview of what's open and spot unnecessary tabs with the grid of thumbnails.


> Tabs aren't just navigation history; they're curated, temporary history. Unworthy of the permanence of bookmarking,

You might enjoy this?

https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/toomanytabs-s...

https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/tree-style-ta...

Also, the person who thinks 30 tabs is a lot should get a look at what I do to myself:

http://heybryan.org/shots/2008-01-15-tabs.png


I don't think tabs with tab recovery is always equivalent to a bookmark list. Personally, I have 30-40 tabs open. This is because I have several projects I work on, any of which I may research in 10 or more tabs. When I switch between projects, I don't want to have to close all the tabs and reopen them. I don't care if they are swapped out of memory, but the access should remain easy. Having to manually bookmark these to come back to them isn't easy.


I was not claiming the problem exist with the user.

Im claiming there is lots of overlap in functionality. The differences are in the default behavior and the UI elements. In the end, it should all be one big directed graph.

I would rather state it the other way around. The fact that people use tabs, means the bookmark functionality is broken from a UX perspective.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: