Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Why doesn't the README file explain what this repository is doing?

It explains exactly what it's doing.

"Microsoft Store package for Windows LTSC."

It provides a Microsoft Store package for LTSC builds, and an install script that allows it to actually work. Windows LTSC builds don't have Microsoft Store preinstalled, and Microsoft offers no official way to re-enable it.



> Windows LTSC builds don't have Microsoft Store preinstalled

No, it's not that it isn't "preinstalled", the Microsoft Store is literally not supported on LTSC, by design. LTSC was never intended to run the Store. The original use case for LTSC was for ATMs, industrial control equipment, hospitals, and the like, where IoT wasn't appropriate, where you needed the ability to run full desktop applications.

> Microsoft offers no official way to re-enable it.

Yeah that's because the Store was never supposed to run on LTSC. It's not supported. Why would they offer an official way to re-enable it? The whole point of LTSC is that it doesn't include the store.

If someone cobbled together an ugly hack to shoehorn it in, by definition it could break at any time.

Which it has.

There is no customer for this.


If by "customer" you mean "way of making money", I agree, since I didn’t pay for it. OTOH, I have been running LTSC on my desktop for years because it's the best edition of Windows, and I haven't had any issues with the Store, which I had to install manually, thus far.


> There is no customer for this.

Lots of people including myself run LTSC to minimize Microsoft shitware.


[flagged]


> Anyone pirating LTSC is by definition not a customer and has no right to make any demands of Microsoft.

Luckily, no demand was made, just a solution offered by the community.


[flagged]


To be fair, the headline could have been better worded. The convention for something like this is

“Show HN: Title of Repo”

I could understand how one might not understand what the aim of this post was. Maybe the ensuing conversation could have been handled better, but I would certainly include the parent comment in that indictment.


> No one is here to make you money or talk about "customers"

Have you ever read this site before? Half of it is about that and startup culture.


I agree it always been pretty implicit part of the culture. Just never seen someone so virulent and blunt about it lol.


Ok, but the brief README links to an actual microsoft.com domain (https://www.microsoft.com/store).

Why would you need a package to wrap a website? Wouldn't the website be accessible on a LTSC build, even if the official package isn't available?

If this is filling a highly useful role that I'm admittedly oblivious to, why are there only three commits in the project history?

(Best I can tell, this is a personal project that somehow made it to HN front page)


The store is also an app on windows and is sometimes an hard dependency to install apps that only exist on the windows store without having to jump through many hoops. It's usually part of windows itself in the regular retail builds of windows, but LTSC which is meant for enterprise and embedded system does not include it. Installing it is not straightforward which is what this repo provides.

There's no source code, it's a just a bunch of binaries and an install/uninstall script.

Edit: I should clarify that the link provided in the repo is not the microsoft store that the apps refer to. This would be a better link https://apps.microsoft.com


Its not just the store - its also the XBOX app/store and the framework to install "modern" applications that are .msix, appx, appxbundle.

I'm not seeing those attached to the repo linked here, and wonder if thats part of the reason why it wont work on older LTSC versions.


I don't think there's anything nefarious going on here but to someone just quickly looking over the page it has the impression of being an official Microsoft project, given the gratuitous use of their trademark and zero mention of it being a "community" effort.


Yeah they do. Run `wsreset.exe -i` in powershell and it'll install the Windows Store after a few minutes.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: