Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Apes Together Strong

Absolutely 100% agree with your statement, Linux desktop is the perfect example of that. You get a billion different distribution that all comes from debian, arch and maybe fedora but that's all.

In my opinion, there should be 3 Linux distribution. That's all.

For instance Ubuntu: Yeah Ubuntu gnome suck, yeah canonical push snap package when flappack are better but do you really need a new distribution because of that ?

Perfection is the enemy of progress. And when things go all bad and you have used all other alternative, then and only then forking should be considered. Like a nuclear button.

Currently i feel like it's more often used by newcomer that want to get to the lead position of a project they are passionate about but didn't start, so they fork and get a fraction of the community behind. It's not much but it's still a bit.




Un(?)fortunately, us Organic Maps forkers have been with the project since Organic Maps was OMaps, and before. The only people with more commits than the senior fork member are the OM co-owners themselves. We really tried getting OM to deliver on their promises, but it seems silence is preferable to accountability for them.


>In my opinion, there should be 3 Linux distribution. That's all.

Initially I instinctively agreed with you - certainly there's too many fragmentation in the Linux distro space!

Then I recalled I use NixOs, and it probably didn't make it to your top 3...


Couldn't nixos main feature be implemented in a mainstream distribution ?

Technically you can install nix package manager on Debian, and what is nixos main interest without it's package manager ?


It manages the entire, immutable, OS with it. That's a completely different paradigm, you cannot simply mix them!


> yeah canonical push snap package when flappack are better but do you really need a new distribution because of that ?

In practice yes, since Canonical is replacing essential system components to depend on snap. So you can't just "not use it", you're forced to be dependent on their upstream package hosting service that you can't rehost yourself.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: