Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I am in the habit of flagging anything related to American politics. It never leads anywhere and seems orthogonal to HN.


Yea, I got tired of people attempting to make comments like this and wrote a script to quickly analyze past comment history to see if they were truly being honest.

You have consistently and reliably posted your political views here. Please don't try to pretend that you hate the political discourse now that people are critical of your guy.


I feel like you could put posters through a sentiment analysis and maybe use that to write a browser plugin to annotate posters on hn.


Ok, but do you want American politics discussion on HN or not? Why the purity test?


First not my guy. I'm not left enough to vote for Trump. Second I can both flag and comment as I did here.


> I'm not left enough to vote for Trump

What can this sentence possibly even mean. Trump is left to you?


You should learn more about the political landscape. It will clear up a lot of these questions. And I mean that sincerely. If you see everything as left or right it’s quite confusing.


Yes that's correct. He's been in office four years prior so we know his record.


There's this growing sentiment among some Republicans that Trump isn't conservative enough and that Democrats, a centrist party relative to most developed nations, are left wing lunatics/socialists/communists.


My mind is blown


I am a regular on HN and I disagree. So, do we cancel each other out?


That's not a bad thing. That's probably how it is suppose to work.


I hope that we were beyond first-past-the-post voting. I would like to see a ranked-choice or star voting to determine whether something should be flagged.

I would also appreciate using tools like this AI system[1] to identify and limit hate-filled posts. It's only accurate about 90% of the time, but that's an acceptable loss for me, even if my speech gets filtered.

[1] https://spectrum.ieee.org/ai-versus-online-hate-speech


"Political" is not a binary true or false. There are plenty of on-topic articles here that merely have "political overlap" as dang[1] puts it, and they should not be flagged. To be fair, this article seems to be more towards the "purely political" side of the spectrum and was probably correctly flagged.

I think this rule is generally followed by HN's users, but for whatever reason, anything that touches "Elon" or "DOGE" always gets insta-buried, whether or not it's tech-related, whether or not it's interesting, whether or not it's worth discussing.

I don't think it's automated bots, but there is most certainly an online Elon Defense Brigade of real users out there trying to bury anything negative about the guy. I don't know what would make someone devote so much time to defending the honor of a billionaire. It's almost religious.

1: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: