I've bounced back and forth between IC and EM (intentionally) and I've seen some that get very very close then completely blow it with one of these. One in particular would put people through management training for a full day each week for months, give them a very senior director, all the "right things" but then cut their IC duties by maybe 10-15% at most and give them a team of 12 people to manage. And they wondered why fully half of new managers wanted to go back to IC work after a year or two.
The best realistic thing I've seen, and my current workplace, is pretty good with small teams and training and all that, but basically doesn't offer any pay increase from upper level IC to first-level management and so you have to be okay with basically 20% more work for the same money. It's not perfect but one benefit is you don't get any managers who are only in it for the money.
I don’t see your contact info in your HN profile but could I get in touch with you to learn more about how teams can get this right? My email is in mine.
