Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

In the end the author expressed his frustration at the lack of input from security professionals, but the words he used were perhaps a little arrogant:

He said "to routinely make preventable mistakes because people with my exact skillset haven’t yet delivered easy-to-use, hard-to-misuse tooling".

I would suggest rephrasing this as a way to make it clear what skills he is referring to, something like "people who are senior security experts". Otherwise it might sound like he is implying that he is the only one who should audit everything, because who else would have the exact same experience that he has had all his life?



> I would suggest rephrasing this as a way to make it clear what skills he is referring to, something like "people who are senior security experts".

Well, it needs to say exactly what it says, not a vague category like "senior security experts".

There are countless developers and security nerds who run circles around me. They can do everything I can do, and more.

A lot of the trappings that cause developers to make preventable mistakes is because my betters and I haven't delivered easy-to-use tools that solve their use cases perfectly, and I feel personally responsible for not being able to help more.

Not sure what's arrogant about that.


Well, just thinking about the meaning of the word "exact" can be literal, the level of frustration suggests the emphasis is the highest, it can make the reader understand the meaning of "exact" is a literal irreducible exact, implying no one other than you have the literal exact same experience.


I'd argue there are easy-to-use tools for this use case, frankly. Buy your employees corporate Yubikeys, issue them over certified mail, and just use gpg in some authenticated mode. That may be too complicated for Grandma Marie and Uncle Paul, but is it seriously too complicated for someone trying to run a software business? How do you ever expect to understand the laws you have to comply with to run a business if that's your attitude?

If that's still too complicated, send each other API keys over Proton Mail. Unless you're an enemy of the Swiss government, I can't think of a reason not to trust them that isn't into serious crackpot territory. If you're actually being targeted by Mossad or the NSA, they can intercept your certified mail anyway. OpenAI would probably cooperate with them besides.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: