Airflow is by far the fastest and most reliable AirPlay implementation I've seen. It's lightning fast. Truly excellent. The app is also super fast for things like video scrubbing.
I wish the app was a more native feeling UI, and I feel they could be doing deeper integration to enable more video playing. I'm a little worried that the app is out of development, but hoping they keep it going for new versions of macOS and AirPlay.
That's good, I hadn't seen that update! I've been using the app for 5+ years and it doesn't appear to have changed its feature set or UI in that time.
My main concern is OS updates and AirPlay protocol changes breaking it, which would mean that it would no longer fulfil its purpose. AirPlay, being a proprietary protocol, is ripe for breaking third party integrations.
Just a side note: I hoped AirPlay was stable after so many years, but everyone may already know that AirPlay 2 is a change that at least in my use case, made all my old Macs running older macOS and AirPlay 1 incompatible with newer third party hardware and hardware that updated firmware to AirPlay 2. Yes, I'm talking about iTunes! At least all my Airport Expresses still work fine! lol
I wouldn't have known that because their "check for updates" function doeesn't seem to work, even when triggered manually. I'm on 3.3.6, which is just a couple point versions behind latest.
I've been a happy paid AirFlow user for about a decade now, but I realize it's small indie sometimes buggy software.
I use it with an LG TV (WebOS) and while it had some trouble in the past, it now works pretty well. Sometimes I need to disconnect&reconnect to the TV if I paused for too long and/or left my laptop sleep, but mostly just works.
The way it turns 5.1 audio into stereo (optionally boosting dialogue) is also quite good for some shows, I wish something as good was available in other players.
I don't think it's out of development. I thought of posting this specifically because I got an update banner when I opened it.
I concur, in particular, being able to quickly scrub a 54GB 4K HDR video and see it flash by on the television is insane. It also works fast on ChromeCasts.
More often I see two or maybe even more software products with the same name. In this case Apache Airflow. The two products serve a totally different purpose. I guess for marketing it would be better to have a unique name.
I think we should start putting the creator name in front of the app name. This seems to be by Bitcave company so it would be Bitcave Airflow vs Apache Airflow. It would be fine to shorten the name with context but use the full name to distinguish.
I think it's beneficial for the product's name to be similar to AirDrop. How popular is Apache Airflow? Looking at their website it seems to be a dead product.
It's not even remotely close to a dead product. I work in platform-layer consulting where the services are quite often for customers who run ML and other data pipelines and Airflow is overwhelmingly the most popular DAG orchestration tool they're using.
I'm very curious what even gives you that impression. If you follow the link to their Github, it's got 38.5k stars, 14.6k forks, 3190 contributors, 92 releases, the most recent commit is from an hour ago. The most recent release is from last month.
I guess that Apache Airflow is more popular than the one linked by OP. Making a Google search for "airflow" in an incognito tab, looking at page 1, I see 5 results related to Apache Airflow, one result related to the OP, and a couple related to air conditioning (this was on Google Australia).
Apache Airflow is extremely popular and one of the most commonly used frameworks in data engineering. I guarantee you it is more popular than this Airflow by an order of magnitude or more.
Is there ANY way to send audio from linux to AirPlay speakers?
(I am NOT asking about making Linux an airplay TARGET, which is what Shairport-sync does.)
Pulseaudio reportedly used to claim to support it, but there are many reports of people trying and none of anyone succeeding.
If you can stream your audio via Google Cast, there are a few Cast -> Airplay bridges. I have one of these running on an RPi (I believe [1]), and it's been pretty much fire and forget.
RAOP Discover is currently at the point «It just works until it doesn't» (like most things zeroconf). Behaves fairly reliably in my experience if you don't mind some latency.
There's something similar-ish... if you have an Apple TV and install VLC, there's a feature that allows you to upload whole video files across your local network, and then play them directly from the Apple TV. It's a bit less conveient than Beamer used to be, but still good enough.
Another past paying Beamer user here. I used it until it stopped working, didn’t update, then was bought by another company for redevelopment and incorporated into a horrendous subscription scheme, compete with hard sell sales.
Does this allow one to e.g. pipe the current audio output on my Mac to my iPhone so I can walk away for a few minutes and keep listening to whatever YT video, Zoom call or Podcast that happens to be playing?
If not, does anyone know of a solution for this? Right now I'm using Jump Desktop which actually does a good job, but consumes lots of extra bandwidth since it also streams the Mac's screen (at near 30fps).
Is this kind of app really needed when you can cast the screen from MacOS to the AppleTV? (or does it not work for other airplay devices or is too slow or something).
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm pretty sure that casting your screen re-encodes the screen image in much lower quality.
Whereas Airflow is sending the original video steam over untouched, for supported codecs like h.264/265. So it maintains the original quality. Including resolutions that may be higher than your screen, like 4K.
Using the screen over AirPlay is the wrong way to go for watching video, for several reasons.
That said, QuickTime Player also supports AirPlay to cast the video to an AirPlay device. I’m struggling to understand why I’d use AirFlow when I can use QuickTime? In my case I use Plex, which even makes QuickTime a moot point. I’ve also used VLC with the VLC AppleTV app; I could see where AirFlow could be an improvement over the rather clunky VLC experience (from what I remember).
Ah, I missed that Airflow was doing transcoding, that sounds like the primary benefit, and one of the big things I use Plex for.
I will day, video formats seem to be much more standard (and compatible with QuickTime) than they were in the pre-h.264 days. Though I do tend to lean toward mp4 over mkv if given an option. I still have a second player around to handle stuff QuickTime fails on, but I only need it a few times per year.
MacOS does have the functionality built in, it just barely works.
It also starts with no errors if it comes across a codec it doesn't like (which is most of them) but then just... doesn't work.
Airplay is a big pile of technical debt and they keep rewiring it every few years and not testing if the implementations talk to each other, so it just gets worse and worse.
Longtime (and satisfied) Airflow user, albeit casting from Windows to an Android TV: it's the only casting tool I've used that plays nice with subtitles. VLC lets you cast to a TV quite easily, but any subtitle data won't survive the jump.
screencasting over airplay sucks for watching stuff, the framerate is just slightly too choppy that its noticeable and annoying, you cant close the lid on your laptop, and you can't easily use it while casting because either you're screen mirroring anyway or your screen has been stretched weirdly because macbooks have their own weird aspect ratio which don't match any TVs.
> your screen has been stretched weirdly because macbooks have their own weird aspect ratio which don't match any TVs.
When you cast your screen to an Apple TV, the TV shows as an extra display on the computer, and allows you to set the aspect ratio however you'd like. Either when extending or mirroring.
i mean when mirroring the macbook screen looks bad, the tv looks fine. the image on the macbook screen gets squished to match the resolution of the tv.
Really solid program. I bought a license years ago because it is the only software that correctly remuxes media for direct play in Chromecast, including surround sound and HDR.
I wish Jellyfin could catch-up with the compatibility level AirFlow has to offer.
Jellyfin has slowly been getting better. Client also makes a big difference. I fought issues with Roku advertising capabilities properly before eventually hitting limits (100Mbps Ethernet) and moving to Nvidia Shield which has been working better (but still had an issue with HDR)
It seems like there's a playful request at the end of the thread for someone to "write a song about bananas" as a joke or diversion. Since you asked me to continue this conversation, here’s a fun
little song about bananas:
---
*Title: Bananarama*
(Verse 1)
Yellow and sunny,
Sweetness and sunny,
Tropical fruit from far away lands.
Bananas, bananas,
Bananarama in my hand.
(Chorus)
Oh oh oh, bananarama!
Filling the kitchen with tropical aroma,
Ripe and delicious, just peel and eat,
Life is better when you have a banana treat!
(Verse 2)
Smooth and creamy inside,
Perfect for pies or blended surprise.
Bananas, bananas,
Nature’s candy on standby.
(Chorus)
Oh oh oh, bananarama!
Filling the kitchen with tropical aroma,
Ripe and delicious, just peel and eat,
Life is better when you have a banana treat!
(Bridge)
Breakfast, dessert, or midday snack,
Bananas are an everyday fact.
From smoothies to bread,
Banana's healthiness makes it best.
(Chorus)
Oh oh oh, bananarama!
Filling the kitchen with tropical aroma,
Ripe and delicious, just peel and eat,
Life is better when you have a banana treat!
---
Feel free to enjoy this song about bananas and share some laughs!
I didn't think my Chromecast was that old (its the puck style) but whenever I try this with VLC using the "Render" menu (on macOS) it just... doesn't work. The Chromecast just never sees it (even though it shows up in the Render menu in VLC)
I wish the app was a more native feeling UI, and I feel they could be doing deeper integration to enable more video playing. I'm a little worried that the app is out of development, but hoping they keep it going for new versions of macOS and AirPlay.