Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> "appears to behave normally in regular matters and is capable of independent living, does not match other DSM symptoms, but believes insane things"

I have met a lot of people in my life who fit this criteria. Not one of them has gone on to become a mass shooter.

Saying we need a phrase to label people like this in order to _stop mass killings_ sounds crazy to me.

If you really had the option to explore the psyche of everyone to the depth necessary to check for "believes insane things" if we could even agree on what that means, I wouldn't be surprised if the test came back positive on 40-70% of the population. A strict enough test and I think we could get that number to 100%.

Isn't it a meme at this point how people win the nobel prize in one field, and then say some nutty nonsense about a completely different field? The human species is rational, insane, brilliant, stupid, compassionate and vicious, ugly and beautiful all at once. All of us.

More compassion for self and others would be my preference.



> Not one of them has gone on to become a mass shooter.

No, but with a few friends getting together, cheering them along, and feeding into their collective insanity, they could very easily get together and do something serious. Most of the insurrectionists (the people who invaded Congress, not the people who went home after attending the rally) in Jan 6th can be described as such. That network of 'friends' is critical for actually motivating them to get off their ass and act on their beliefs.

> More compassion for self and others would be my preference.

The problem is that it's much easier to violently destroy, than it is to create, and the damage that a group of angry people who believe an utterly insane thing is disproportionate.


> Isn't it a meme at this point how people win the nobel prize in one field, and then say some nutty nonsense about a completely different field?

There is a name for that; it's the "Nobel Disease" or "Nobel Syndrome". Sometimes people swap "Nobel" and "MD".




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: