Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

How is this a replacement for LangSmith? I browsed the source and I could only find what appear to be a few small helper functions for emitting structured logs.

I’m less familiar with LangSmith, but browsing their site suggests they happen to offer observability into LLM interactions in addition to other parts of the workflow lifecycle. This just seems to handle logging and you have to pass all the data yourself- it’s not instrumenting an LLM client, for example.






> in addition to other parts of the workflow lifecycle

FWIW this is primarily based on the LangChain framework so it's fairly turnkey, but has no integration with the rest of your application. You can use the @traceable decorator in python to decorate a custom function in code too, but this doesn't integrate with frameworks like OpenTelemetry, which makes it hard to see everything happens.

So for example, if your LLM feature is plugged into another feature area in the rest of your product, you need to do a lot more work to capture things like which user is involved, or if you did some post-processing on a response later down the road, what steps might have had to be taken to produce a better response, etc. It's quite useful for chat apps right now, but most enterprise RAG use cases will likely want to instrument with OpenTelemetry directly.


LangSmith integrates with OpenTelemetry: https://blog.langchain.dev/opentelemetry-langsmith/

Neat! Missed that one earlier this month, good to see.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: