Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> just to have a place to live, intelligent robots cleaning your house etc

Animals could say precisely the same thing about living in a zoo!

(1) Who determines the allocation of resources in your utopia? How do you handle an ever increasing population that depends on the biosphere which itself is the only source of raw materials and energy for the incredible amount of energy required for it?

(2) People need a purpose. Most people will find a life of really doing nothing quite boring. Like it or not, people want some control over their destiny, and not to be animals in a cage.

(3) If people really don't need each other, what will happen to the social fabric? If AI can really do everything for us, then what is to stop some people from killing all the rest and taking everything for themselves? We have only relative morals that function when they are necessary, and some people not even that.






Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: